Current:Home > StocksSupreme Court justice sues over Ohio law requiring certain judicial candidates to use party labels-LoTradeCoin
Supreme Court justice sues over Ohio law requiring certain judicial candidates to use party labels
View Date:2024-12-23 16:49:33
COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — A top jurist and former elections chief in Ohio has sued two state officials over a recently passed law that requires certain judicial candidates to declare their party affiliation on ballots.
Ohio Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Brunner argues in the lawsuit filed Tuesday that the 2021 law violates the free speech, due process and equal protection clauses of the U.S. Constitution because it subjects candidates like her to different rules for fundraising and campaigning than their potential nonjudicial rivals.
That’s partly because candidates for those court positions are subject to “significant prohibitions of certain conduct” under Ohio’s judicial code of conduct, Brunner argues in U.S. District Court in Youngstown, including any kind of “political or campaign activity that is inconsistent with the independence, integrity, or impartiality of the judiciary.”
The legal challenge was filed against Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose and Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost in their roles as the state’s top elections and legal officers, respectively. Brunner served as secretary of state from 2007 to 2011.
Besides adding party labels, the new law made additional ballot changes. Those included placing Supreme Court candidates on ballots directly below candidates for statewide offices and Congress, who typically use party labels, and separating high court candidates from county and municipal judicial candidates, who run without party labels.
Brunner, a Democrat, noted the close timing of the law’s introduction at the Republican-controlled Statehouse to her declaration of candidacy for chief justice in 2021. She lost that race to fellow Justice Sharon Kennedy, a Republican, after having handily won a nonpartisan race for justice in 2020. Brunner’s initial election to Ohio’s 7-member high court followed the election of two other Democrats — both in nonpartisan races — in 2018, a rare win for the party in the GOP-dominated state.
Prior to the law, Ohio’s practice of leaving judicial candidates’ party affiliation off the general ballot went back more than 160 years. Before that, the Ohio General Assembly appointed judges.
During debate on the issue, some voters said they vote less frequently for judicial candidates than other offices on their ballots because of a lack of information about them, according to a 2014 Ohio Judicial Elections Survey.
More than half of respondents of the survey said a party label would be “very” or “somewhat” helpful in judicial elections.
LaRose’s spokeswoman said the office does not comment on pending litigation. Yost’s spokesperson didn’t immediately reply to a request for comment.
veryGood! (67228)
Related
- Deebo Samuel explains 'out of character' sideline altercation with 49ers long snapper, kicker
- Senate investigation argues FBI, DHS officials downplayed or failed to properly share warnings of violence on Jan. 6
- 16 Game-Winning Ted Lasso Gift Ideas That Will Add Positivity to Your Life
- Beginning of the End for Canada’s Tar Sands or Just a Blip?
- Kevin Costner Shares His Honest Reaction to John Dutton's Controversial Fate on Yellowstone
- DeSantis unveils border plan focused on curbing illegal immigration
- Zendaya and Tom Holland’s Future on Spider-Man Revealed
- Vanderpump Rules Tease: Tom Sandoval Must Pick a Side in Raquel Leviss & Scheana Shay's Feud
- Texas now tops in SEC? Miami in trouble? Five overreactions to college football Week 11
- Teen Wolf's Tyler Posey Engaged to Singer Phem
Ranking
- Ryan Reynolds Makes Dream Come True for 9-Year-Old Fan Battling Cancer
- Climate Change Could Bring Water Bankruptcy With Grave Consequences
- American Climate Video: The Driftwood Inn Had an ‘Old Florida’ Feel, Until it Was Gone
- Offset and His 3 Sons Own the Red Carpet In Coordinating Looks
- Skiing legend Lindsey Vonn ends retirement, plans to return to competition
- American Climate Video: A Pastor Taught His Church to See a Blessing in the Devastation of Hurricane Michael
- Climate Change Could Bring Water Bankruptcy With Grave Consequences
- New York man shot crossbow that killed infant daughter, authorities say
Recommendation
-
Georgia remains part of College Football Playoff bracket projection despite loss
-
US Declares Greenhouse Gases a Danger to Public Health and Welfare
-
Megan Fox and Machine Gun Kelly Prove Their Twin Flame Is Burning Bright During London Outing
-
Jenna Dewan Pens Sweet Message to Her and Channing Tatum's Fierce Daughter Everly on 10th Birthday
-
Arbitrator upholds 5-year bans of Bad Bunny baseball agency leaders, cuts agent penalty to 3 years
-
Tom Sandoval, Raquel Leviss Can't Believe They're Labeled Pathological Liars After Affair
-
Poor Nations to Drop Deforestation Targets if No Funding from Rich
-
GOP-led House panel accuses cybersecurity agency of violating citizens' civil liberties