Current:Home > ScamsMeta attorneys ask judge to dismiss shareholder suit alleging failure to address human trafficking-LoTradeCoin
Meta attorneys ask judge to dismiss shareholder suit alleging failure to address human trafficking
View Date:2024-12-23 16:47:21
WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) — Attorneys for Meta Platforms and several of its current and former leaders, including founder Mark Zuckerberg, are asking a Delaware judge to dismiss a shareholder lawsuit alleging the company has deliberately failed to protect users of its social media platforms from human trafficking and child sexual exploitation.
The lawsuit, filed last year by several investment funds, claims that Meta’s directors and senior executives have long known about rampant human trafficking and child sexual exploitation on Facebook and Instagram, but have failed to address the predatory behavior.
“For years, Meta’s directors and senior executives have known that pedophiles and human and sex traffickers have been using Facebook and Instagram to facilitate their noxious activities,” plaintiffs’ attorney Christine Mackintosh told Vice Chancellor J. Travis Laster during a hearing Tuesday. “But despite this, Meta’s directors utterly failed to implement board level oversight and controls to ferret out these heinous activities and to stop them from proliferating on Meta’s platforms.”
David Ross, an attorney for Meta, argued that the lawsuit should be dismissed because the alleged conduct of the company’s leaders has not resulted in Meta suffering “corporate trauma” as required by Delaware law. The company also argues that the lawsuit’s claims are based on speculation that it might face future harm or loss.
The plaintiffs contend, however, Meta has already suffered harm, including sharp drops in its share price and market capitalization amid media reports about trafficking and child sex abuse involving its platforms. They also point to “massive legal defense costs” in related litigation and allege that Meta also has suffered “reputational harm.”
Meta also argues that the lawsuit must be dismissed because the plaintiffs failed to demand that the board take action before filing their lawsuit. Such a demand is typically required before a shareholder can file a “derivative complaint” on behalf of a corporation over alleged harm to the company caused by its officers or directors.
The plaintiffs say the demand requirement should be excused as “futile” because board directors are defendants who face a substantial likelihood of liability, and many are beholden to Zuckerberg instead of being independent.
Mackintosh said Meta directors have ignored several red flags, including lawsuits, media reports, shareholder resolutions, and increasing scrutiny by lawmakers and regulators of online activity, that should have alerted the board to act. Documents provided by the company in response to the lawsuit, she added, suggest little if any board discussions regarding human trafficking and child sexual exploitation.
Under Delaware law, corporate directors can be held liable for failing to exercise proper oversight to ensure legal compliance with relevant statutes. Laster noted, however, that there has been debate in legal circles on whether Delaware’s law regarding director oversight can be applied to business risks, not just legal compliance.
“If we were going to have a business risk that actually could trigger this, it seems like not dealing with a massive child porn problem might be a good one,” said Laster, who said he will rule at a later date.
veryGood! (95)
Related
- The results are in: Peanut the Squirrel did not have rabies, county official says
- A police raid of a Kansas newsroom raises alarms about violations of press freedom
- Maui wildfire crews continue to fight flare-ups in Lahaina and inland, as death toll rises past 90
- Argentine peso plunges after rightist who admires Trump comes first in primary vote
- Lululemon, Disney partner for 34-piece collection and campaign: 'A dream collaboration'
- 3 Maryland vacationers killed and 3 more hurt in house fire in North Carolina’s Outer Banks
- Fiery crash scatters exploding propane bottles across Mississippi highway, driver survives
- Coast Guard rescues 4 divers who went missing off the Carolinas
- Georgia House Republicans stick with leadership team for the next two years
- Funyuns and flu shots? Gas station company ventures into urgent care
Ranking
- Celtics' Jaylen Brown calls Bucks' Giannis Antetokounmpo a 'child' over fake handshake
- Derek Carr throws a TD pass in his Saints debut, a 26-24 preseason win over the Chiefs
- Highest-paid QBs in the NFL: The salaries for the 42 highest paid NFL quarterbacks
- ‘Nobody Needs to Know’ by Pidgeon Pagonis, August Wilson biography: 5 new must-read books
- Kennesaw State football coach Brian Bohannon steps down after 10 seasons amid first year in FBS
- Pennsylvania house explosion: 5 dead, including child, and several nearby homes destroyed
- Police apologize after Black teen handcuffed in an unfortunate case of 'wrong place, wrong time'
- Man charged with murder, wife with tampering after dead body found at their Texas property
Recommendation
-
Fighting conspiracy theories with comedy? That’s what the Onion hopes after its purchase of Infowars
-
‘No Labels’ movement says it could offer bipartisan presidential ticket in 2024
-
Survival of Wild Rice Threatened by Climate Change, Increased Rainfall in Northern Minnesota
-
Horoscopes Today, August 12, 2023
-
FC Cincinnati player Marco Angulo dies at 22 after injuries from October crash
-
The best horror movies of 2023 so far, ranked (from 'Scream VI' to 'Talk to Me')
-
Former Mississippi officers expected to plead guilty to state charges for racist assault
-
Biden administration urges colleges to pursue racial diversity without affirmative action