Current:Home > FinanceNorth Carolina judge properly considered jurors’ request in murder trial, justices decide-LoTradeCoin
North Carolina judge properly considered jurors’ request in murder trial, justices decide
View Date:2024-12-23 15:31:44
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A North Carolina judge properly used his discretion in declining to provide testimony transcripts to jurors deliberating in a murder trial, the state Supreme Court has ruled.
A majority of justices on Thursday overturned the state Court of Appeals’ order of a new trial for Tevin Demetrius Vann.
Vann was convicted in 2019 of first-degree murder in 2016 death of Ashley McLean, who was found dead inside a Wilmington hotel room. The jury also found Vann guilty of felony murder of McLean’s unborn child and robbery with a dangerous weapon. He was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
While Superior Court Judge Henry Stevens provided to jurors other trial-related documents, including a transcript of Vann’s interview with detectives, he declined to give them the opportunity to review trial testimony of Vann, a police detective and the medical examiner.
Stevens told jurors “it’s your duty to recall their testimony. So you will have to remember that. We’re not – we can’t provide a transcript as to that.”
A Court of Appeals panel determined in 2022 that Stevens’ decision was prejudicial error against Vann, particularly because his testimony differed from his earlier interrogation with police when he admitted to striking McLean and fleeing the hotel room with her cell phone. On the stand, he asserted he did not attack McLean and only previously confessed to avoid being charged with murder.
In Thursday’s opinion backed by five court members, Associate Justice Phil Berger wrote there was no prejudicial error because the case record showed the trial court “understood and properly exercised its discretion.” He cited in part how Stevens handled previous requests from the deliberating jurors.
Associate Justice Anita Earls wrote a dissenting opinion, saying a new trial was proper because it was clear Stevens believed he could not provide the transcripts of Vann’s testimony, which she said was crucial and central to the case.
In a separate opinion, Associate Justice Allison Riggs wrote that while Stevens erred on the request, it was wrong to order a new trial because there lacked a reasonable possibility that jurors would have reached a different result based on other evidence against Vann.
veryGood! (479)
Related
- The results are in: Peanut the Squirrel did not have rabies, county official says
- Hunger Games' Rachel Zegler Reveals the OMG Story Behind Her First Meeting With Jennifer Lawrence
- Erin Andrews Breaks Down in Tears Detailing Moment She Learned She'd Been Secretly Videotaped
- Cease-fire is the only way forward to stop the Israel-Hamas war, Jordanian ambassador says
- Mechanic dies after being 'trapped' under Amazon delivery van at Florida-based center
- Iowa superstar Caitlin Clark to join ManningCast Monday night on ESPN2 for Chiefs-Eagles
- Shakira Reveals Why She Decided to Finally Resolve Tax Fraud Case for $7.6 Million
- After trying to buck trend, newspaper founded with Ralph Nader’s succumbs to financial woes
- The Daily Money: Mattel's 'Wicked' mistake
- Close friends can help you live longer but they can spread some bad habits too
Ranking
- Trump is likely to name a loyalist as Pentagon chief after tumultuous first term
- Zach Wilson benched in favor of Tim Boyle, creating murky future with Jets
- ACC out of playoff? Heisman race over? Five overreactions from Week 12 in college football
- Nearly 1,000 Rohingya refugees arrive by boat in Indonesia’s Aceh region in one week
- Ex-Phoenix Suns employee files racial discrimination, retaliation lawsuit against the team
- 3 teen girls plead guilty, get 20 years in carjacking, dragging death of 73-year-old woman
- 'The price of admission for us is constant hate:' Why a Holocaust survivor quit TikTok
- Man facing murder charges in disappearance of missing Washington state couple
Recommendation
-
Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul stirs debate: Is this a legitimate fight?
-
'Most sought-after Scotch whisky' sells for record $2.7M at London auction
-
Deep sea explorer Don Walsh, part of 2-man crew to first reach deepest point of ocean, dies at 92
-
After trying to buck trend, newspaper founded with Ralph Nader’s succumbs to financial woes
-
Mark Zuckerberg Records NSFW Song Get Low for Priscilla Chan on Anniversary
-
Black Friday shopping sales have started. Here's what you need to know.
-
NFL Week 11 winners, losers: Broncos race back to relevance with league-best win streak
-
'We're all one big ohana': Why it was important to keep the Maui Invitational in Hawaii