Current:Home > BackAI industry is influencing the world. Mozilla adviser Abeba Birhane is challenging its core values-LoTradeCoin
AI industry is influencing the world. Mozilla adviser Abeba Birhane is challenging its core values
View Date:2024-12-23 20:00:11
“Scaling up” is a catchphrase in the artificial intelligence industry as tech companies rush to improve their AI systems with ever-bigger sets of internet data.
It’s also a red flag for Mozilla’s Abeba Birhane, an AI expert who for years has challenged the values and practices of her field and the influence it’s having on the world.
Her latest research finds that scaling up on online data used to train popular AI image-generator tools is disproportionately resulting in racist outputs, especially against Black men.
Birhane is a senior adviser in AI accountability at the Mozilla Foundation, the nonprofit parent organization of the free software company that runs the Firefox web browser. Raised in Ethiopia and living in Ireland, she’s also an adjunct assistant professor at Trinity College Dublin.
Her interview with The Associated Press has been edited for length and clarity.
Q: How did you get started in the AI field?
A: I’m a cognitive scientist by training. Cog sci doesn’t have its own department wherever you are studying it. So where I studied, it was under computer science. I was placed in a lab full of machine learners. They were doing so much amazing stuff and nobody was paying attention to the data. I found that very amusing and also very interesting because I thought data was one of the most important components to the success of your model. But I found it weird that people don’t pay that much attention or time asking, ‘What’s in my dataset?’ That’s how I got interested in this space. And then eventually, I started doing audits of large scale datasets.
Q: Can you talk about your work on the ethical foundations of AI?
A: Everybody has a view about what machine learning is about. So machine learners — people from the AI community — tell you that it doesn’t have a value. It’s just maths, it’s objective, it’s neutral and so on. Whereas scholars in the social sciences tell you that, just like any technology, machine learning encodes the values of those that are fueling it. So what we did was we systematically studied a hundred of the most influential machine learning papers to actually find out what the field cares about and to do it in a very rigorous way.
A: And one of those values was scaling up?
Q: Scale is considered the holy grail of success. You have researchers coming from big companies like DeepMind, Google and Meta, claiming that scale beats noise and scale cancels noise. The idea is that as you scale up, everything in your dataset should kind of even out, should kind of balance itself out. And you should end up with something like a normal distribution or something closer to the ground truth. That’s the idea.
Q: But your research has explored how scaling up can lead to harm. What are some of them?
A: At least when it comes to hateful content or toxicity and so on, scaling these datasets also scales the problems that they contain. More specifically, in the context of our study, scaling datasets also scales up hateful content in the dataset. We measured the amount of hateful content in two datasets. Hateful content, targeted content and aggressive content increased as the dataset was scaled from 400 million to 2 billion. That was a very conclusive finding that shows that scaling laws don’t really hold up when it comes to training data. (In another paper) we found that darker-skinned women, and men in particular, tend to be allocated the labels of suspicious person or criminal at a much higher rate.
Q: How hopeful or confident are you that the AI industry will make the changes you’ve proposed?
A: These are not just pure mathematical, technical outputs. They’re also tools that shape society, that influence society. The recommendations are that we also incentivize and pay attention to values such as justice, fairness, privacy and so on. My honest answer is that I have zero confidence that the industry will take our recommendations. They have never taken any recommendations like this that actually encourage them to take these societal issues seriously. They probably never will. Corporations and big companies tend to act when it’s legally required. We need a very strong, enforceable regulation. They also react to public outrage and public awareness. If it gets to a state where their reputation is damaged, they tend to make change.
veryGood! (5617)
Related
- Dwayne Johnson Admits to Peeing in Bottles on Set After Behavior Controversy
- Taco Bell's new box meals make it easy to cook a crunchwrap or quesadilla at home
- President of Belarus gives himself immunity from prosecution and limits potential challengers
- Former cycling world champ Rohan Dennis reportedly charged after Olympian wife Melissa Hoskins killed by car
- Horoscopes Today, November 12, 2024
- Capitol riot, 3 years later: Hundreds of convictions, yet 1 major mystery is unsolved
- 3-year-old Tennessee boy dies after being struck with a stray bullet on New Year's Eve
- Woman sues Jermaine Jackson over alleged sexual assault in 1988
- Jennifer Garner Details Navigating Grief 7 Months After Death of Her Dad William Garner
- Sudan paramilitary leader says he’s committed to cease-fire, but no progress on proposed peace talks
Ranking
- Jax Taylor Breaks Silence on Brittany Cartwright Dating His Friend Amid Their Divorce
- Bachelor Nation's Adam Gottschalk Says Bryan Abasolo Put All He Could Into Rachel Lindsay Marriage
- California forces retailers to have 'gender-neutral' toy aisles. Why not let kids be kids?
- The Excerpt podcast: E-bikes are everywhere. Can we navigate with them safely?
- See Leonardo DiCaprio's Transformation From '90s Heartthrob to Esteemed Oscar Winner
- House Speaker Mike Johnson urges Biden to use executive action at the southern border
- This Valentine's Day, let Sweethearts 'Situationship Boxes' have the awkward conversations
- New dog breed recognized by American Kennel Club: What to know about the Lancashire Heeler
Recommendation
-
Miami Marlins hiring Los Angeles Dodgers first base coach Clayton McCullough as manager
-
ASOS Just Added Thousands of Styles to Their 80% Sale to Start Your New Year Off With a Bang
-
Voters file an objection to Trump’s name on the Illinois ballot
-
Tom Sandoval slammed by 'Vanderpump Rules' co-stars for posing with captive tiger
-
Man who stole and laundered roughly $1B in bitcoin is sentenced to 5 years in prison
-
Body found in freezer at San Diego home may have been woman missing for years, police say
-
Natalia Grace Adoption Case: How Her Docuseries Ended on a Chilling Plot Twist
-
Nordstrom Quietly Put Tons of SKIMS Styles on Sale Up to 50% Off— Here's What I’m Shopping