Current:Home > MarketsWisconsin GOP leader silent on impeachment of Supreme Court justice after earlier floating it-LoTradeCoin
Wisconsin GOP leader silent on impeachment of Supreme Court justice after earlier floating it
View Date:2024-12-23 20:12:17
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Wisconsin’s top Republican state lawmaker, who had threatened to possibly impeach a newly elected liberal state Supreme Court justice if she didn’t step down from a redistricting case, didn’t mention that option Monday in his first comments since the justice decided against recusal.
Justice Janet Protasiewicz declined late Friday to recuse from the redistricting case and sided with the liberal majority of the court to take up the lawsuit, which seeks to overturn Republican-drawn legislative maps. Republican lawmakers argued she had to recuse because she said during her campaign that the GOP-drawn maps were “rigged” and “unfair” and because she accepted nearly $10 million from the Wisconsin Democratic Party.
Protasiewicz on Friday rejected those arguments, noting that other justices have accepted campaign cash and not recused from cases. She also noted that she never promised or pledged to rule on the redistricting lawsuit in any way.
Wisconsin Assembly Speaker Robin Vos had threatened to consider impeaching Protasiewicz if she didn’t recuse from the case. On Monday, in his first public statement since she declined to recuse, Vos did not mention impeachment as an option. He did not return a text message asking if his comments meant impeachment was now off the table.
“Justice Protasiewicz should have recused herself,” Vos said. “We think the United States Supreme Court precedent compels her recusal, and the United States Supreme Court will have the last word here.”
It is up to each justice on the state Supreme Court to decide whether to recuse from a case. It’s unclear from Vos’s statement if he intended to file a legal challenge over Wisconsin’s recusal rules with the U.S. Supreme Court or if he was talking about the larger redistricting case, which could end up before the nation’s highest court.
The Supreme Court on Friday, in agreeing to take the redistricting challenge, said it would only consider legal questions related to contiguity of districts and separation of powers questions. It set oral arguments for Nov. 21.
“Justice Protasiewicz is asking to be taken at her word that she will apply the law,” Vos said. “Given the Wisconsin Supreme Court is limiting its review of the redistricting case to two questions, legal contiguity and separation of powers, applying the law should be straightforward.”
Vos has asked former justices to study the possibility of impeachment, while not yet committing to take that unprecedented step.
“Never once will you find me saying that if she didn’t recuse, we’re going to impeach. I never said that,” Vos said. “What I did say is that is wrong if she doesn’t. She needs to recuse herself if you predetermine an outcome.”
veryGood! (59)
Related
- As the transition unfolds, Trump eyes one of his favorite targets: US intelligence
- How the EPA assesses health risks after the Ohio train derailment
- 2 adults killed, baby has life-threatening injuries after converted school bus rolls down hill
- The Impossibly Cute Pika’s Survival May Say Something About Our Own Future
- Suspect arrested after deadly Tuskegee University homecoming shooting
- Allow Zendaya and Tom Holland to Get Your Spidey Senses Tingling With Their Romantic Trip to Italy
- Study Finds Rise in Methane in Pennsylvania Gas Country
- A Longchamp Resurgence Is Upon Us: Shop the Iconic Le Pliage Tote Bags Without Paying Full Price
- Trump's election has women swearing off sex with men. It's called the 4B movement.
- She was declared dead, but the funeral home found her breathing
Ranking
- What does the top five look like and other questions facing the College Football Playoff committee
- 6 Ways Trump’s Denial of Science Has Delayed the Response to COVID-19 (and Climate Change)
- 18 Bikinis With Full-Coverage Bottoms for Those Days When More Is More
- Politicians say they'll stop fentanyl smugglers. Experts say new drug war won't work
- Judith Jamison, acclaimed Alvin Ailey American dancer and director, dead at 81
- All 5 meerkats at Philadelphia Zoo died within days; officials suspect accidental poisoning
- A new study offers hints that healthier school lunches may help reduce obesity
- Standing Rock Tribe Prepares Legal Fight as Dakota Oil Pipeline Gets Final Approval
Recommendation
-
QTM Community Introduce
-
U.S. Intelligence Officials Warn Climate Change Is a Worldwide Threat
-
Coronavirus ‘Really Not the Way You Want To Decrease Emissions’
-
Hilary Duff Reveals She Follows This Gwyneth Paltrow Eating Habit—But Here's What a Health Expert Says
-
Champions Classic is for elite teams. So why is Michigan State still here? | Opinion
-
Iconic Forests Reaching Climate Tipping Points in American West, Study Finds
-
Vanderpump Rules Finale Bombshells: The Fallout of Scandoval & Even More Cheating Confessions
-
Her husband died after stay at Montana State Hospital. She wants answers.