Current:Home > FinanceHawaii judge orders a new environmental review of a wave pool that foes say is a waste of water-LoTradeCoin
Hawaii judge orders a new environmental review of a wave pool that foes say is a waste of water
View Date:2024-12-23 18:33:13
HONOLULU (AP) — A judge has halted plans for an artificial wave pool until developers can revise an environmental assessment to address concerns raised by Native Hawaiians and others who say the project is unnecessary in the birthplace of surfing and a waste of water.
In granting a temporary injunction Tuesday, Hawaii Environmental Court Judge Shirley Kawamura ordered a new review of concerns including impacts on water supply and anticipated growth in the area.
A group of Native Hawaiians and other residents filed a lawsuit last year challenging the Hawaii Community Development Authority’s approval of the 19-acre (7.6-hectare) Honokea Surf Village planned for west Oahu, which found that it will have no significant environmental impacts.
Opponents of the project say the wave pool, with a capacity of 7 million gallons (26 million liters), isn’t needed less than 2 miles (3.2 kilometers) from the ocean and another existing wave pool.
Project backer and renowned Native Hawaiian waterman Brian Keaulana has said artificial waves are useful for competitive surfers to train on perfect breaks that are sometimes elusive in the ocean. Customizable surf, he said, can also help create ideal conditions to teach surfing and lifesaving skills.
“Our goal of creating a place that combines cultural education with skill-based recreation must be done in a way that does not harm our natural resources,” he said Wednesday in a statement. “The court’s ruling allows us an opportunity to revisit the environmental concerns, especially our water resources.”
The judge said in her ruling that there was “insufficient evidence for the HCDA to determine whether there is a likelihood of irrevocable commitment of natural resources and whether secondary and cumulative impacts of water use, injection, land use changes, and wildlife mitigation would likely lead to a significant impact, thereby favoring an injunction.”
The current assessment is “ambiguous as to the specific manner, time frame, and actual daily water use implicated by the initial and periodic filling of the lagoon,” the ruling said.
However the development authority did make sufficient assessment of potential impact on historic preservation and burials, it added. The HCDA declined to comment Wednesday on the ruling.
Developers say the project would be drawing from a private water company separate from Oahu’s water utility, using a supply that was committed decades ago.
But the judge noted that they draw from the same underlying aquifer.
“Thus, additional analysis is needed to fully capture the potential cumulative impact of anticipated growth and subsequent increased competing water demand,” the ruling said.
The state attorney general’s office said it was reviewing the decision.
Healani Sonoda-Pale, one of the plaintiffs, called the ruling a “pono decision,” using a Hawaiian word that can mean “righteous.”
“Much has been made about Hawaiians being on both sides of the issue,” she said. “Building a wave pool is not a cultural practice. The threat of a wave pool ... is so immense in terms of how many people it could affect.”
veryGood! (86285)
Related
- Ex-Duke star Kyle Singler draws concern from basketball world over cryptic Instagram post
- Henry Kissinger, revered and reviled former U.S. diplomat, turns 100
- Russia used starvation tactics against Ukraine civilians, investigators claim in new war crime allegation
- Australia police offer $1 million reward in case of boy who vanished half a century ago
- UFC 309: Jon Jones vs. Stipe Miocic fight card, odds, how to watch, date
- First Daughter Ashley Biden Reveals Her Mantra For Dealing with Criticism of Her Family
- Vanderpump Rules' Lala Kent Says She Suspected Tom Sandoval and Raquel Leviss Affair
- Kelly Clarkson Seemingly Calls Out Ex Brandon Blackstock and Divorce Drama in abcdefu Song Cover
- Why Cynthia Erivo Needed Prosthetic Ears for Wicked
- Chinese fighter jet harassed U.S. Air Force spy plane over South China Sea
Ranking
- Suspect arrested after deadly Tuskegee University homecoming shooting
- Katie Holmes Makes Rare Comment About Daughter Suri Cruise While Reflecting on Dawson's Creek Days
- Remains of Indiana soldier killed during World War II identified
- Bear blamed for Italy runner's death in Alps gets reprieve from being euthanized for now
- Seattle man faces 5 assault charges in random sidewalk stabbings
- Sephora 24-Hour Flash Sale: 50% Off Dermalogica, Urban Decay, Clinique, PMD, and More
- Prince William and Kate show up for royal wedding of Jordan's own Crown Prince Hussein and Rajwa Alseif
- Revive Dry, Damaged Hair With This Mask That Makes My Strands Luxuriously Soft With the Glossiest Shine
Recommendation
-
Oil Industry Asks Trump to Repeal Major Climate Policies
-
A Japanese lunar lander crashed into the moon. NASA just found the evidence.
-
Why Kelly Ripa Has PTSD From Working on Live
-
Iran frees 3 Europeans in prisoner swap as detained American's lawyer denies rumors of imminent release
-
Colorado police shot, kill mountain lion after animal roamed on school's campus
-
Watch 2023 Human Rights Watch Film Festival documentaries in NYC and at home
-
Ulta 24-Hour Flash Sale: Take 50% Off Grande Cosmetics, Sunday Riley, Origins, L'Occitane, and More
-
Prince William and Kate show up for royal wedding of Jordan's own Crown Prince Hussein and Rajwa Alseif