Current:Home > NewsJudge signals Trump "hush money" case likely to stay in state court-LoTradeCoin
Judge signals Trump "hush money" case likely to stay in state court
View Date:2025-01-11 05:34:19
Former President Donald Trump's efforts to move his New York State "hush money" criminal case to federal jurisdiction were met by a skeptical judge Tuesday, who indicated he didn't believe payments made to a former Trump attorney were tied to Trump's service as president.
Lawyers for Trump and Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg argued during the two-and-half-hour hearing over whether reimbursements to Trump's former attorney, Michael Cohen, were made as official acts tied to Trump's presidency. Trump's lawyers say the case belongs in federal court — not the state court where Bragg's prosecutors typically work — because the payments were made while Trump was president.
Judge Alvin Hellerstein said Tuesday that he would issue his decision in two weeks, but indicated he was unswayed by Trump's argument that the payments were within the "color of (Trump's) office."
The payments had "no relationship to any act relating to the president," Hellerstein said.
Trump entered a not guilty plea on April 4 to 34 state felony counts of falsification of business records. The case revolves around a series of transactions between Trump and Cohen. Manhattan prosecutors say the payments were obscured reimbursements for a "hush money" payment made to adult film star Stormy Daniels days before the 2016 presidential election.
Attorneys for Trump say he is immune from state prosecution for acts "performed when carrying out his federal duties." Tuesday's hearing included a surprise witness called by Trump's lawyers — Trump Organization executive vice president and chief legal officer Alan Garten — who caught Bragg's prosecutors off guard because they were unaware he might be called.
Garten testified that after Trump took office, his company forwarded matters involving the president and first lady to Cohen.
He also testified that after Trump took office, Cohen served as personal attorney to the president, and that "presidential had to be separated from personal" due to "corporate policies."
Cohen said in a phone call with CBS News Tuesday, "I don't see the relevance" of Garten's testimony.
"The documentary evidence in the possession of the district attorney contradicts Garten," Cohen said.
Bragg's office has adamantly opposed Trump's effort to move the case to federal court, and like the judge, does not believe the payments were made "within the 'color of his office.'"
"The objective of the alleged conduct had nothing to do with [Trump's] duties and responsibilities as President," wrote Manhattan prosecutor Matthew Colangelo in a May 30 filing. "Instead, the falsified business records at issue here were generated as part of a scheme to reimburse defendant's personal lawyer for an entirely unofficial expenditure that was made before defendant became President."
The push to move the case has gone forward as attorneys for Trump have also sought a new state court judge. They asked in a June 1 filing that New York judge Juan Merchan recuse himself.
Last year, Merchan presided over the trial of two Trump Organization companies that were found guilty of 17 counts related to criminal tax evasion. Trump's motion accuses Merchan of encouraging the prosecution's key witness in that case, former Trump Organization CFO Allen Weisselberg, to testify against the companies. It also notes that Merchan's daughter has worked for a Democratic consulting firm, and that he made a pair of donations — totaling $35 — to Democratic groups during the 2020 election cycle.
Bragg's office opposes the recusal and Merchan has not announced a decision.
Ash Kalmar contributed reporting for this story.
- In:
- Donald Trump
- Stormy Daniels
veryGood! (3445)
Related
- Judge sets date for 9/11 defendants to enter pleas, deepening battle over court’s independence
- Kim Kardashian's SKIMS Presidents' Day Deals: Save Up to 50% On These 25 Top-Selling Styles
- After 'Felicity' and a stint as a spy, Keri Russell embraces her new 'Diplomat' role
- Parisians overwhelmingly vote to expel e-scooters from their streets
- Anti-abortion advocates press Trump for more restrictions as abortion pill sales spike
- 2023 Whiting Awards recognize 10 emerging writers
- How Motherhood Has Forever Changed Ashley Greene's Outlook on Body Image
- Nordstrom Winter Sale: Shop a $128 Sweater for $38 & 50% Off Levi's, Kate Spade, Free People & More
- Messi breaks silence on Inter Miami's playoff exit. What's next for his time in the US?
- Pink Explains Why the Lady Marmalade Music Video Wasn't Fun to Make
Ranking
- Kentucky governor says investigators will determine what caused deadly Louisville factory explosion
- Seymour Stein, the record executive who signed Madonna, is dead at 80
- Former model accuses onetime Harvey Weinstein associate of sexual assault
- Rebel Wilson and Ramona Agruma Are Engaged
- Voters in Oakland oust Mayor Sheng Thao just 2 years into her term
- The Best Presidents' Day Fashion Sales to Shop From Kate Spade, Coach, Free People & More
- 'Pretty Baby' chronicles Brooke Shields' career and the sexualization of young girls
- Kourtney Kardashian and Travis Barker Get Cozy on Snowy Valentine's Day Trip
Recommendation
-
Mike Tyson has lived a wild life. These 10 big moments have defined his career
-
See Gisele Bündchen Recreate Her 2004 Rio Carnival Look Nearly 20 Years Later
-
From Daft Punk to ballet: Thomas Bangalter makes full swing to classical
-
The 73 Best Presidents’ Day Beauty Deals: Fenty Beauty, Tarte, Olaplex, Isle of Paradise, MAC, and More
-
Artem Chigvintsev Returns to Dancing With the Stars Ballroom Amid Nikki Garcia Divorce
-
Jonathan Majors on his meteoric rise through Hollywood
-
Nick Jonas Shares How Priyanka Chopra, Sophie Turner and Danielle Jonas Influence Jonas Brothers' Music
-
Here's a few of our favorite photos from the 2023 Dreamville Music Festival