Current:Home > BackThe Supreme Court rules against California woman whose husband was denied entry to US-LoTradeCoin
The Supreme Court rules against California woman whose husband was denied entry to US
View Date:2024-12-23 18:35:27
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Friday ruled against a California woman who said her rights were violated after federal officials refused to allow her husband into the country, in part, because of the way his tattoos were interpreted.
The 6-3 decision along ideological lines found that citizens don’t necessarily have the right to participate in federal government decisions about whether immigrant spouse s can legally live in the U.S.
“While Congress has made it easier for spouses to immigrate, it has never made spousal immigration a matter of right,” said Justice Amy Coney Barrett, reading from the bench the majority opinion joined by her fellow conservatives.
While a citizen “certainly has a fundamental right to marriage” Barrett said, “it is a fallacy to leap from that premise to the conclusion that United States citizens have a fundamental right that can limit how Congress exercises the nation’s sovereign power to admit or exclude foreigners.”
In a dissent joined by her liberal colleagues, Justice Sonia Sotomayor said that denying citizens the right to seek specific reasons about why their spouses are denied entry, “gravely undervalues the right to marriage in the immigration context.”
The majority ruled against Los Angeles civil rights attorney Sandra Muñoz, who was last able to live with her Salvadoran husband nearly 10 years ago.
The couple started the process of getting an immigrant visa after they married in 2010. Luis Asencio-Cordero, who had been living in the U.S. without legal status, had to travel to the consulate in San Salvador to complete the process.
But once there, the consular officer denied his application and cited a law denying entry to people who could participate in unlawful activity.
The State Department would not give a more specific reason, but after filing a lawsuit they learned the refusal was based, in part, on a consular officer’s determination that his tattoos likely meant he was associated with the gang MS-13.
Asencio-Cordero has denied any association with any gang and has no criminal history. The tattoos, including Our Lady of Guadalupe, theatrical masks and a profile of psychologist Sigmund Freud, instead expressed his intellectual interests and Catholic faith, his lawyers said in court papers.
The U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals sided with Muñoz and ordered the State Department to share the reason and reconsider the visa application.
That ruling was tossed out by the Supreme Court after the State Department appealed.
___
The Associated Press writer Fatima Hussein contributed to this report.
veryGood! (366)
Related
- Why Suits' Gabriel Macht Needed Time Away From Harvey Specter After Finale
- Princess Anne returns home after hospitalization for concussion
- Pennsylvania Senate passes bill to bar universities and pension funds from divesting from Israel
- Ohio teen accused of having school hit list pleads guilty to inducing panic
- Congress returns to unfinished business and a new Trump era
- Mia Goth and Ti West are on a mission to convert horror skeptics with ‘MaXXXine’
- Bill Gates’ Daughter Jennifer Is Pregnant, Expecting Baby No. 2 With Husband Nayel Nassar
- Why Simone Biles is 'close to unstoppable' as she just keeps getting better with age
- These Yellowstone Gift Guide Picks Will Make You Feel Like You’re on the Dutton Ranch
- Photo Gallery: Americans watch Trump and Biden in election debate
Ranking
- DWTS' Gleb Savchenko Shares Why He Ended Brooks Nader Romance Through Text Message
- Princess Anne returns home after hospitalization for concussion
- Arizona wound care company charged for billing older patients about $1 million each in skin graft scheme
- How do bees make honey? A scientist breaks down this intricate process.
- Cavaliers' Darius Garland rediscovers joy for basketball under new coach
- Tesla Bay Area plant ordered to stop spewing toxic emissions after repeated violations
- Shannen Doherty Shares Heartbreaking Perspective on Dating Amid Cancer Battle
- Dawn Staley to receive Jimmy V Award for Perseverance at ESPYS
Recommendation
-
'I was in total shock': Woman wins $1 million after forgetting lotto ticket in her purse
-
Matthew Perry’s Ketamine Suppliers Could Face Charges Over His Death
-
North Carolina legislators leave after successful veto overrides, ballot question for fall
-
Arizona wound care company charged for billing older patients about $1 million each in skin graft scheme
-
Diamond Sports Group can emerge out of bankruptcy after having reorganization plan approved
-
Intrigue of NHL draft expected to begin after the Sharks likely select Celebrini with top pick
-
Biden campaign, DNC highlight democracy, Jan. 6 in lead-up to debate
-
John O’Keefe, the victim in the Karen Read trial, was a veteran officer and devoted father figure