Current:Home > MyCourt largely sides with Louisiana sheriff’s deputies accused in lawsuit of using excessive force-LoTradeCoin
Court largely sides with Louisiana sheriff’s deputies accused in lawsuit of using excessive force
View Date:2024-12-23 19:57:09
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — A federal appeals court has largely sided with two white Louisiana sheriff’s deputies in a lawsuit filed by a Black woman, rejecting her claims that they used excessive force against her as they investigated an allegation she had been riding a motorcycle without a helmet.
Teliah Perkins was arrested outside her home in 2020. She later sued two St. Tammany Parish Sheriff’s Office deputies on behalf of herself and her son, who video-recorded the arrest.
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said in its opinion Nov. 30 that excessive force claims must be tossed out but added the suit can proceed against one of the deputies, Ryan Moring, over an allegation he unconstitutionally interfered with the son’s efforts to record the arrest.
“The video evidence conclusively demonstrates that neither Deputy employed excessive force to subdue Perkins, who just as conclusively was resisting arrest,” three 5th Circuit judges said.
U.S. District Judge Wendy Vitter had refused to dismiss the civil case last year against Moring and Deputy Kyle Hart, ruling that there was evidence of constitutional violations against Perkins and her son, then 14, arising from the May 2020 arrest for resisting an officer. During arguments earlier this year at the 5th Circuit, the deputies’ lawyer told the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that Vitter’s ruling was wrong and that video clearly shows the officers’ actions were justified.
Vitter had ruled that the evidence of constitutional rights being violated overcame the deputies’ claim that the suit should be thrown out under the doctrine of “qualified immunity,” which protects police from lawsuits arising from the scope of their work.
Attorneys for the deputies argued that the appeals court has the right to throw out the case at this stage based on three videos by the son and others that he said clearly show the officers’ actions were justifiable.
During the 5th Circuit hearing in May, exactly what the videos show and how they should be interpreted was at issue — including whether Perkins was choked at some point during her arrest.
Perkins and her son were represented by attorneys with the American Civil Liberties Union of Louisiana. The organization noted the partial victory in a statement Wednesday. “The ruling underscores that police intimidation of witnesses who record police officers engaged in brutality cannot stand,” it said in part.
But the ACLU firmly disagreed with the dismissal of the excessive force claims, saying the case should have been allowed to proceed to the trial phase for a jury to decide whether undue force was used.
The appellate judges in the case were James Ho and Cory Wilson, nominated to the 5th Circuit by former President Donald Trump, and Jennifer Walker Elrod, nominated by former President George W. Bush. Vitter was nominated to the federal bench by Trump.
Ho dissented from the part of the Nov. 30 decision allowing action against Moring to continue over his attempt to stop the filming of the arrest. “The Constitution does not compel police officers to affirmatively help a citizen secure the ideal camera angle while that citizen is actively berating the police just a few feet away from an active physical struggle with another person,” Ho wrote.
veryGood! (38851)
Related
- Zendaya Shares When She Feels Extra Safe With Boyfriend Tom Holland
- 'Can I go back to my regular job?' Sports anchor goes viral for blizzard coverage
- Jurassic Park Actress Ariana Richards Recreates Iconic Green Jello Scene 30 Years Later
- The Senate’s Two-Track Approach Reveals Little Bipartisanship, and a Fragile Democratic Consensus on Climate
- Fantasy football buy low, sell high: 10 trade targets for Week 11
- Larsa Pippen and Marcus Jordan Respond to Criticism of Their 16-Year Age Gap
- What Does a Zero-Carbon Future Look Like for Transportation in Minnesota?
- From Twitter chaos to TikTok bans to the metaverse, social media had a rocky 2022
- Stock market today: Asian stocks dip as Wall Street momentum slows with cooling Trump trade
- Florida lawyer arrested for allegedly killing his father, who accused him of stealing from family trust
Ranking
- Chet Holmgren injury update: Oklahoma City Thunder star suffers hip fracture
- Trump special counsel investigations cost over $9 million in first five months
- Newark ship fire which claimed lives of 2 firefighters expected to burn for several more days
- We battle Planet Money for indicator of the year
- Jessica Simpson's Husband Eric Johnson Steps Out Ringless Amid Split Speculation
- Trump says he'd bring back travel ban that's even bigger than before
- Residents Want a Stake in Wisconsin’s Clean Energy Transition
- If You Can't Stand Denim Shorts, These Alternative Options Will Save Your Summer
Recommendation
-
Missouri prosecutor says he won’t charge Nelly after an August drug arrest
-
Warming Trends: A Facebook Plan to Debunk Climate Myths, ‘Meltdown’ and a Sad Yeti
-
New York bans pet stores from selling cats, dogs and rabbits
-
Tired of Wells That Threaten Residents’ Health, a Small California Town Takes on the Oil Industry
-
Pete Alonso's best free agent fits: Will Mets bring back Polar Bear?
-
Investors prefer bonds: How sleepy government bonds became the hot investment of 2022
-
Inside a Southern Coal Conference: Pep Rallies and Fears of an Industry’s Demise
-
After the Fukushima disaster, Japan swore to phase out nuclear power. But not anymore