Current:Home > Contact-usThe Justice Department says there’s no valid basis for the judge to step aside from Trump’s DC case-LoTradeCoin
The Justice Department says there’s no valid basis for the judge to step aside from Trump’s DC case
View Date:2024-12-23 16:00:09
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department is challenging efforts by former President Donald Trump to disqualify the Washington judge presiding over the case charging him with plotting to overturn the results of the 2020 election.
Prosecutors with special counsel Jack Smith’s team wrote in a court filing late Thursday that there was “no valid basis” for U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan to recuse herself.
Trump’s lawyers filed a long-shot motion earlier this week urging Chutkan to step aside, citing comments she made in separate sentencing hearings related to the Jan. 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol that they say taint the Trump proceedings and call into question whether she has already prejudged the Republican former president’s guilt.
In one such hearing, Chutkan told a defendant who was sentenced to more than five years in prison that he had “made a very good point” that the “people who exhorted” and encouraged him “to go and take action and to fight” had not been charged. Chutkan added that she did not “make charging decisions” and had no “influence on that.”
“I have my opinions,” she said, “but they are not relevant.”
But the Justice Department said the Trump team had taken Chutkan’s comments out of context and failed to show that she harbored any bias against the former president, who lost the 2020 election to Democrat Joe Biden and falsely claimed the election was stolen from him.
The Justice Department said the statements the Trump lawyers had cited show the judge simply doing her job — responding to, and rejecting, efforts to minimize their own culpability by pointing the finger at Trump, who had told his supporters to “fight like hell” at a rally shortly before the deadly Capitol insurrection.
Chutkan did not say, prosecutors wrote, that Trump was legally or morally to blame for the events of Jan. 6 or that he deserved to be punished.
“Although the defendant tries to claim otherwise, the Court’s statements about which he complains are core intrajudicial statements — statements that the Court made while performing its official duties, in direct response to the arguments before it, and which were derived from knowledge and experience the Court gained on the bench,” the prosecutors wrote.
They added: “As such, to mount a successful recusal claim based on the cited statements, the defendant must show that they display a deep-seated animosity toward him. The defendant cannot meet this heavy burden.”
Trump’s motion is unlikely to succeed given the high standard for recusal. A similar effort to seek the recusal of a judge in a separate New York prosecution he faces was unsuccessful.
___
Follow Eric Tucker on X at http://www.twitter.com/etuckerAP.
veryGood! (97121)
Related
- Suspected shooter and four others are found dead in three Kansas homes, police say
- 'Five Nights at Freddy's' movie pulls off a Halloween surprise: $130.6 million worldwide
- Police arrest 22-year-old man after mass shooting in Florida over Halloween weekend
- Firearms charge against Washington state senator Jeff Wilson dismissed in Hong Kong court
- NFL Week 10 injury report: Live updates on active, inactive players for Sunday's games
- Ohio woman accused of killing 4 men with fatal fentanyl doses to rob them pleads not guilty
- Gigi Hadid, Ashley Graham and More Stars Mourn Death of IMG Models' Ivan Bart
- Suspect detained in an explosion that killed 3 people at a Jehovah’s Witness gathering in India
- Lions find way to win, Bears in tough spot: Best (and worst) from NFL Week 10
- These US cities will experience frigid temperatures this week
Ranking
- NFL coaches diversity report 2024: Gains at head coach, setbacks at offensive coordinator
- China Evergrande winding-up hearing adjourned to Dec. 4 by Hong Kong court
- Alaska's snow crabs suddenly vanished. Will history repeat itself as waters warm?
- Back from the dead? Florida man mistaken as dead in fender bender is very much alive
- 32 things we learned in NFL Week 10: Who will challenge for NFC throne?
- FIFA bans Spain's Luis Rubiales for 3 years for unwanted kiss at World Cup
- Iran arrests rights lawyer after she attended funeral for girl injured in mysterious Metro incident
- Simone Biles dons different gold, attends Packers game to cheer on husband Jonathan Owens
Recommendation
-
Artem Chigvintsev Returns to Dancing With the Stars Ballroom Amid Nikki Garcia Divorce
-
Police arrest 22-year-old man after mass shooting in Florida over Halloween weekend
-
Willie Nelson looks back on 7 decades of songwriting in new book ‘Energy Follows Thought’
-
She talked about depression at a checkup — and got billed for two visits.
-
School workers accused of giving special needs student with digestive issue hot Takis, other abuse
-
Suspect arrested in Tampa shooting that killed 2, injured 18
-
Idaho left early education up to families. One town set out to get universal preschool anyway
-
Mass shootings over Halloween weekend leave at least 11 dead across US