Current:Home > FinanceNorth Carolina court says speedway can sue top health official over COVID-19 closure-LoTradeCoin
North Carolina court says speedway can sue top health official over COVID-19 closure
View Date:2024-12-23 18:53:06
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A North Carolina racetrack shuttered briefly for defying state gathering limits during the pandemic can sue the top health regulator on allegations that Gov. Roy Cooper’s administration violated the constitutional rights of its operators by trying to make an example out of it, the state Supreme Court ruled Friday.
The justices agreed unanimously that counterclaims that Ace Speedway in Alamance County and its owners filed seeking financial damages can continue, agreeing with a Court of Appeals panel in 2022 and a trial judge that refused to throw them out. That lawsuit was filed weeks after a judge in 2020 helped enforce then-Health and Human Services Secretary Mandy Cohen’s order to stop the track from holding events unless they complied with Cooper’s statewide executive order that included crowd-size limits.
State lawyers representing Kody Kinsley — Cohen’s successor — argued the speedway was cited because it repeatedly and publicly violated the law, and that sovereign immunity blocks such litigation against a state official. They also said COVID-19 gathering limits were temporary and served a proper governmental purpose to protect the public during the “early and uncertain stages of an unprecedented global pandemic.”
But the Supreme Court agreed the speedway’s attorney made plausible legal claims that the state infringed on rights for people to enjoy “the fruits of their own labor” and conducted ”unlawful selective enforcement” of its order against the speedway. The substance of those claims have yet to be judged in court.
“We emphasize that these allegations remain unproven,” Associate Justice Richard Dietz wrote in the court’s opinion, but “these allegations assert colorable claims under the North Carolina Constitution for which there is no alternative remedy,” and thus litigation is allowed.
The ruling hands a legal defeat to the Democratic governor by a court composed of five registered Republicans and two Democrats. The case now returns to trial court to be heard. The state Department of Health and Human Services is reviewing the decision, a spokesperson said.
Three days after Cooper issued a May 2020 executive order placing a 25-person cap on all outdoor gatherings, Ace Speedway hosted approximately 2,550 spectators for its first race of the season.
Racetrack operator Robert Turner spoke out against the restrictions and said his racetrack would remain open for all attendees. A sign posted on site at a subsequent race that June labeled the 2,000-person gathering a “peaceful protest of injustice and inequality everywhere,” the lawsuit states.
When the short-track speedway continued to draw crowds of 1,000 or more, Cooper’s office ordered the Alamance County sheriff to intervene. After the sheriff refused, the Cooper administration declared Ace Speedway an “imminent hazard” for the spread of COVID-19 and called for its closure until the order expired. Turner alleged that Cooper treated his business differently than other outdoor venues because of his vocal opposition.
Such restrictions have long expired. State attorneys argued if counterclaims were allowed to continue, they would “hamstring the government’s ability to effectively address future public health crises and other emergencies,” Kinsley’s legal brief read.
Dietz wrote that at this stage of the case the Ace Speedway allegations must be taken as true. And if Cooper did indeed single out the business for enforcement because of Turner’s outcry, then the order would have not held a proper governmental purpose, Dietz said.
Chuck Kitchen, an attorney representing the speedway operators, praised Friday’s decision, saying the speedway was shut down for nearly an entire racing season.
Other court cases involving the governor’s powers in health emergencies are pending.
The state Supreme Court has agreed to hear a pair of cases filed by operators of standalone bars who said Cooper’s executive orders forcing them to remain shuttered for safety while restaurants that serve alcohol got to reopen violated the state constitution. Court of Appeals panels have sided with the bar and taverns. Kitchen, who is also representing plaintiffs in one of the bar cases, said the bar litigation could address more broadly whether the executive orders were unlawful even without selective enforcement allegations.
veryGood! (716)
Related
- 5-year-old boy who went missing while parent was napping is found dead near Oregon home, officials say
- Two Indiana police officers are acquitted of excessive force in 2020 protesters’ arrests
- Coco Austin Reveals How She Helped Her and Ice-T's Daughter Chanel Deal With a School Bully
- Live updates | Israel strikes north and south Gaza after US vetoes a UN cease-fire resolution
- Kennesaw State football coach Brian Bohannon steps down after 10 seasons amid first year in FBS
- Anthony Davis leads Lakers to NBA In-Season Tournament title, 123-109 over Pacers
- Tomb holding hundreds of ancient relics unearthed in China
- Over 300 Rohingya Muslims fleeing Myanmar arrive in Indonesia’s Aceh region after weeks at sea
- Mike Tyson-Jake Paul: How to watch the fight, time, odds
- 3 people killed and 1 wounded in shooting at Atlanta apartment building, police say
Ranking
- NFL MVP rankings: Does Steelers QB Russell Wilson deserve any consideration?
- Tensions are soaring between Guyana and Venezuela over century-old territorial dispute
- 'Wait Wait' for December 9, 2023: With Not My Job guest Fred Schneider
- Captive in a chicken coop: The plight of debt bondage workers
- Eva Longoria Shares She and Her Family Have Moved Out of the United States
- Iran bans Mahsa Amini’s family from traveling to receive the European Union’s top human rights prize
- Asteroid will pass in front of bright star Betelgeuse to produce a rare eclipse visible to millions
- Chris Evert will miss Australian Open while being treated for cancer recurrence
Recommendation
-
John Robinson, former USC Trojans and Los Angeles Rams coach, dies at 89
-
Ukraine condemns planned Russian presidential election in occupied territory
-
Texas Supreme Court temporarily halts ruling allowing woman to have emergency abortion
-
4 coffee table art books from 2023 that are a visual feast
-
Princess Kate makes rare public appearance after completing cancer chemo
-
Tomb holding hundreds of ancient relics unearthed in China
-
'Tis The Season For Crazy Good Holiday Deals at Walmart, Like $250 Off A Dyson Vacuum
-
Why Shohei Ohtani will be worth every penny of $700 million contract for Los Angeles Dodgers