Current:Home > InvestSmartmatic’s suit against Newsmax over 2020 election reporting appears headed for trial-LoTradeCoin
Smartmatic’s suit against Newsmax over 2020 election reporting appears headed for trial
View Date:2024-12-23 19:18:26
DOVER, Del. (AP) — A lawsuit pitting an electronic voting machine manufacturer that was targeted by allies of former President Donald Trump against a conservative news outlet that aired accusations of vote manipulation in the 2020 election appears headed to trial, following a Delaware judge’s ruling Thursday.
Florida-based Smartmatic is suing Newsmax, claiming the cable network’s hosts and guests made false and defamatory statements after the election implying that Smartmatic participated in rigging the results, and that its software was used to switch votes.
Newsmax, also based in Florida, argues that it was simply reporting on serious and newsworthy allegations being made by Trump and his supporters, including former New York City Mayor Rudy Guiliani and conservative attorney Sidney Powell.
Attorneys for both sides asked Superior Court Judge Eric Davis to rule in their favor without holding a trial, which is scheduled to start Sept. 30. On Thursday, Davis granted partial summary judgment to each side but said a jury must decide several key issues.
“Statements regarding Smartmatic software or voting machines altering the results of the election are factually false,” wrote Davis, who noted that Smartmatic did not provide any election machines or software used in the 2020 election outside of Los Angeles.
However, the judge said that not every allegedly defamatory statement published by Newsmax, including statements about Smartmatic’s ties to Venezuela and its late president Hugo Chavez, has been shown to be materially false.
“Therefore, the court will allow Newsmax to contest falsity as to Smartmatic’s connections with Venezuela,” he wrote.
In court papers, Newsmax has described Smartmatic as “a struggling election technology company with a checkered history” that is using a legally baseless and unconstitutional theory of liability to try to obtain a massive windfall.
Last month, a federal grand jury in Florida indicted three current and former executives of Smartmatic in a scheme to pay more than $1 million in bribes to put its voting machines in the Philippines. Prosecutors allege that Smartmatic’s Venezuelan-born co-founder, Roger Piñate, colluded with others to funnel bribes to the chairman of the Philippines’ electoral commission using a slush fund created by overcharging for each voting machine it supplied authorities.
In a favorable ruling for Newsmax, Davis rejected Smartmatic’s claim that the news outlet acted with “express malice” under Florida law, meaning that its primary motivation was to injure Smartmatic.
“There is no evidence that Newsmax acted with evil intent towards Smartmatic,” the judge wrote.
Davis previously ruled that Smartmatic is a “limited public figure” for purposes of defamation and must show that Newsmax acted with “actual malice” by knowingly and recklessly disregarding the truth. On Thursday, he said actual malice is an issue for a jury, and that a jury also must decide whether Smartmatic is entitled to damages.
In another blow to Smartmatic, Davis said Newsmax can argue that it is protected from liability under Florida’s “neutral reporting privilege,” which extends to “disinterested and neutral reporting” on matters of public concern. Newsmax argues that the privilege applies because many of the allegedly defamatory statements were made by third parties appearing as guests, or were rebroadcast after being made by third parties on non-Newsmax platforms.
“With these facts, a reasonable jury could find Newsmax was reporting on a matter of public concern without endorsing the allegations surrounding the election,” he wrote, adding that a jury could also find that Newsmax’s reporting was not neutral.
Davis also said Newsmax could assert a “fair reporting privilege” regarding reporting by White House correspondent Emerald Robinson about a whistleblower affidavit filed in a Georgia lawsuit challenging the election results. The affidavit involved claims by Powell that Smartmatic had colluded with the Venezuelan government in that country’s 2013 presidential election.
Newsmax argues that Florida’s fair reporting privilege applies to accurate reporting on judicial proceedings, including court records, and that Robinson was reporting on the contents of an affidavit filed in federal court. Smartmatic contends that the affidavit was not signed or sworn, and therefore not an official document. Davis said a jury must decide whether the fair reporting privilege applies to Robinson, who erroneously reported that the affidavit was sworn.
The Delaware lawsuit, which takes issue with 24 Newsmax reports over a five-week period in late 2020, is one of several stemming from reports by conservative news outlets following the election. Smartmatic also is suing Fox News for defamation in New York and recently settled a lawsuit in the District of Columbia against the One America News Network, another conservative outlet.
Dominion Voting Systems similarly filed several defamation lawsuits against those who spread conspiracy theories blaming its election equipment for Trump’s loss. Last year, in a case presided over by Davis, Fox News settled with Dominion for $787 million.
veryGood! (6)
Related
- After years of unrest, Commanders have reinvented their culture and shattered expectations
- Imagining a World Without Fossil Fuels
- Utilities Seize Control of the Coming Boom in Transmission Lines
- Selena Quintanilla's Husband Chris Perez Reunites With Her Family After Resolving Legal Dispute
- Rafael dissolves into a low pressure system in the Gulf of Mexico after hitting Cuba as a hurricane
- Logging Plan on Yellowstone’s Border Shows Limits of Biden Greenhouse Gas Policy
- Suspected Long Island Serial Killer in Custody After Years-Long Manhunt
- Karlie Kloss Gives Birth, Welcomes Baby No. 2 With Husband Joshua Kushner
- Ford agrees to pay up to $165 million penalty to US government for moving too slowly on recalls
- Gov. Moore Commits Funding for 67 Hires in Maryland’s Embattled Environment Department, Hoping to Fix Wastewater Treatment Woes
Ranking
- Oklahoma school district adding anti-harassment policies after nonbinary teen’s death
- Teen Mom 2's Nathan Griffith Arrested for Battery By Strangulation
- Barbenheimer opening weekend raked in $235.5 million together — but Barbie box office numbers beat Oppenheimer
- Adrienne Bailon-Houghton Reveals How Cheetah Girls Was Almost Very Different
- Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul fight odds will shift the longer the heavyweight bout goes
- UN Water Conference Highlights a Stubborn Shortage of Global Action
- Jamie Foxx addresses hospitalization for the first time: I went to hell and back
- Why Saving the Whales Means Saving Ourselves
Recommendation
-
'I was in total shock': Woman wins $1 million after forgetting lotto ticket in her purse
-
Antarctic Researchers Report an Extraordinary Marine Heatwave That Could Threaten Antarctica’s Ice Shelves
-
Here Are The Biggest Changes The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 2 Made From the Books
-
John Cena’s Barbie Role Finally Revealed in Shirtless First Look Photo
-
Who will save Florida athletics? Gators need fixing, and it doesn't stop at Billy Napier
-
What Denmark’s North Sea Coast Can Teach Us About the Virtues of Respecting the Planet
-
Patrick Mahomes Is Throwing a Hail Mary to Fellow Parents of Toddlers
-
Public Lands in the US Have Long Been Disposed to Fossil Fuel Companies. Now, the Lands Are Being Offered to Solar Companies