Current:Home > FinanceNorth Carolina voter ID lawsuit heading for trial after judge declines to end challenge-LoTradeCoin
North Carolina voter ID lawsuit heading for trial after judge declines to end challenge
View Date:2024-12-23 11:57:26
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A federal trial over North Carolina’s photo voter dentification law remains set for May after a judge refused Wednesday to end efforts by civil rights groups that sued over the requirement on allegations that its provisions are marred by racial bias.
U.S. District Judge Loretta Biggs denied a “summary judgment” motion filed 2 1/2 years ago for the State Board of Elections, which is implementing the 2018 ID law enacted by the Republican-controlled General Assembly. After legal delays in state and federal courts, the photo ID requirement under that law began with municipal elections last fall and the March 5 primaries.
Attorneys for GOP legislative leaders also defending the law had told Biggs that they supported the board’s motion, which if granted would have meant the law’s defenders would have prevailed without additional evidence or testimony. A trial is scheduled to begin May 6.
The state NAACP and several local chapters contend that the photo ID mandate, along with other provisions in the law, violate the U.S. Constitution and the Voting Rights Act by discriminating disproportionately against Black and Latino residents trying to vote.
State attorneys for the elections board wrote in their 2021 motion that NAACP’s evidence doesn’t show discriminatory intent by the legislature, and that burdens imposed on voters who lacked ID are “extremely limited.” Compared to a 2013 voter ID law that was struck down, the 2018 law expands the number of qualifying IDs.
Biggs wrote she was denying the board’s motion in part because “genuine disputes” over the facts in the case are present, and otherwise the legal parties “dispute the inferences which may reasonably be drawn from key undisputed facts.”
In late 2019, Biggs had issued a preliminary injunction blocking enforcement of the law, saying it was tainted because the 2013 law had been struck down on similar grounds of racial bias. But the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed her decision, writing that Biggs had put too much emphasis on the past conduct of the General Assembly when evaluating the 2018 law.
On Wednesday, Biggs mentioned the reversal but said the defendants weren’t necessarily entitled to a favorable ruling now because the standards for summary judgment are different. Any appeal of summary judgment decisions usually can happen after a trial.
Previous trial dates for the case have been postponed — once when the U.S. Supreme Court weighed Biggs’ earlier refusal to allow GOP lawmakers to join the case and defend the law in court. The U.S. justices sided with the legislative leaders in 2022.
Biggs opened the door to move this case along last summer after the state Supreme Court determined the photo ID law comported with state constitution.
veryGood! (2845)
Related
- Footage shows Oklahoma officer throwing 70-year-old to the ground after traffic ticket
- Tom Holland Shares What He Appreciates About Girlfriend Zendaya
- British Museum loan to Greece coincides with dispute over demand to return Parthenon Marbles
- Jason Kelce's Wife Kylie Shows Subtle Support for Taylor Swift Over Joe Alwyn Rumors
- Firefighters make progress, but Southern California wildfire rages on
- An Arkansas deputy fatally shot a man who fled from an attempted traffic stop, authorities say
- Spotify slashes 17% of jobs in third round of cuts this year
- Shooting in Dallas kills 4, including toddler; suspect at large
- Olympic champion Lindsey Vonn is ending her retirement at age 40 to make a skiing comeback
- Putin to discuss Israel-Hamas war during a 1-day trip to Saudi Arabia and UAE
Ranking
- Volunteer firefighter accused of setting brush fire on Long Island
- Who can and cannot get weight-loss drugs
- Stock market today: Asian shares slip ahead of key US economic reports
- Ford, Jeep, and Jaguar among 79,000 vehicles recalled: Check car recalls here
- Mike Tyson employs two trainers who 'work like a dream team' as Jake Paul fight nears
- Michigan soldier killed in Korean War to be buried next week at Arlington National Cemetery
- Video shows elderly 17-year-old Shih Tzu rescued from air vent in Virginia home: Watch
- US, allies in talks on naval task force to protect shipping in Red Sea after Houthi attacks
Recommendation
-
Is the stock market open on Veterans Day? What to know ahead of the federal holiday
-
Dolphins' Tua Tagovailoa reveals strategy on long TD passes to blazing fast Tyreek Hill
-
Maine loon population dips for a second year, but biologists are optimistic about more chicks
-
Illinois halts construction of Chicago winter migrant camp while it reviews soil testing at site
-
Atlanta man dies in shootout after police chase that also kills police dog
-
Supreme Court to hear major case that could upend tax code and doom wealth tax proposals
-
Michigan soldier killed in Korean War to be buried next week at Arlington National Cemetery
-
It's money v. principle in Supreme Court opioid case