Current:Home > ScamsGeorgia case over railroad’s use of eminent domain could have property law implications-LoTradeCoin
Georgia case over railroad’s use of eminent domain could have property law implications
View Date:2024-12-23 18:49:32
ATLANTA (AP) — It’s a fight over land in one of rural Georgia’s poorest areas, but it could have implications for property law across the state and nation.
A hearing is scheduled to begin Monday to help determine whether a railroad can legally condemn property to build a rail line 4.5 miles (7.25 kilometers) long that would serve a rock quarry and possibly other industries.
A hearing officer will take up to three days of testimony, making a recommendation to the five elected members of the Georgia Public Service Commission, who will ultimately decide.
The line would be built by the Sandersville Railroad, which is owned by an influential Georgia family. It would connect to the CSX railroad at Sparta, allowing products to be shipped widely. Sparta is about 85 miles (135 kilometers) southeast of Atlanta.
People in the rural neighborhood don’t want a train track passing through or near their property, in part because they think it would enable expansion at a quarry owned by Heidelberg Materials, a publicly traded German firm.
Some residents already dislike the quarry because it generates noise, dust and truck traffic. Supporters say if the railroad is built, the quarry will move its operation farther from houses, trains will reduce trucks on roads and the railroad will build berms to shield residents.
But owners say losing a 200-foot (60-meter) wide strip of property to the railroad would spoil land they treasure for its peace and quiet, hunting, fishing and family heritage.
“Sandersville Railroad does not care about the destruction of my family’s property or our way of life,” Donald Garret Sr., one of the owners, said in written testimony in August. “They just care about their own plans for my property, which won’t serve the public, but will just help them expand their business and the quarry’s business.”
Opponents have high-powered allies, including the Institute for Justice, which hopes to use the case to chip away at eminent domain, the government power to legally take private land while paying fair compensation.
The Libertarian-leaning legal group was on the losing side of a landmark 2005 case allowing the city of New London, Connecticut, to take land from one private owner and transfer it to another private owner in the name of economic development. The decision set off a widespread reaction, including more than 20 states passing laws to restrict eminent domain.
Railroads have long had the power of eminent domain, but Georgia law says such land seizures must be for “public use.” Opponents targeted the project by saying it would only benefit the quarry and doesn’t meet the definition of public use.
“This is not a taking of necessity from private property owners to serve truly public interests and the public as a whole. Rather, this is a naked wealth transfer,” Daniel Kochan, a law professor at Virginia’s George Mason University, testified for opponents.
The Sandersville Railroad says there are other users, including a company co-located with the quarry that blends gravel and asphalt for paving. Several companies have said they would truck products from the Sandersville area and load them onto the short line, noting they want access to CSX, but opponents question whether that business will materialize.
The case matters because private entities need to condemn private land not only to build railroads, but also to build other facilities such as pipelines and electric transmission lines. There’s a particular need to build additional electric transmission lines in Georgia and other states to transmit electricity from new solar and wind generation.
Sandersville Railroad President Ben Tarbutton III said in testimony that the Institute for Justice is engaged in “transparent efforts to change federal and state constitutional law regarding condemnation.”
Others who live nearby, organized as the No Railroad In Our Community Coalition, are represented by the Southern Poverty Law Center. Janet Paige Smith, a leader of the group, testified the railroad would further burden a neighborhood with many Black retirees on fixed incomes.
“We already suffer from traffic, air pollution, noise, debris, trash, and more from the Heidelberg Quarry, but this project would make everything worse,” Smith testified.
veryGood! (61795)
Related
- As US Catholic bishops meet, Trump looms over their work on abortion and immigration
- Here Are The Best Deals From Wayfair's Memorial Day Sale 2024: Up to 83% Off Furniture, Appliances & More
- Jan. 6 defendant nicknamed Sedition Panda convicted of assaulting law enforcement officer
- Globe-trotting archeologist who drew comparisons to Indiana Jones dies at age 94
- Opinion: Chris Wallace leaves CNN to go 'where the action' is. Why it matters
- 2024 Monaco Grand Prix: F1 schedule, how to watch, and odds for race winner
- Ranked-choice voting has challenged the status quo. Its popularity will be tested in November
- At North Carolina’s GOP convention, governor candidate Robinson energizes Republicans for election
- Get $103 Worth of Tatcha Skincare for $43.98 + 70% Off Flash Deals on Elemis, Josie Maran & More
- Lionel Messi’s Vancouver absence is unfortunate, but his Copa América run is paramount to U.S.
Ranking
- Olivia Munn Randomly Drug Tests John Mulaney After Mini-Intervention
- Memorial Day kicks off summer grilling season. Follow these tips to avoid food illnesses
- Top assassin for Sinaloa drug cartel extradited to US to face charges, Justice Department says
- How many points did Caitlin Clark score last night? Rookie held in check by Las Vegas Aces
- The USDA is testing raw milk for the avian flu. Is raw milk safe?
- Mom who went viral exploring a cemetery for baby name inspo explains why she did it
- Lenny Kravitz tells Gayle King about his insecurities: I still have these moments
- Grayson Murray dies at age 30 a day after withdrawing from Colonial, PGA Tour says
Recommendation
-
Wildfire map: Thousands of acres burn near New Jersey-New York border; 1 firefighter dead
-
Italian teenager Carlo Acutis to become first millennial Catholic saint after second miracle attributed to him
-
Jackie Robinson is rebuilt in bronze in Colorado after theft of statue from Kansas park
-
Why Julianne Hough's Kinrgy Workout Class Will Bring You to Tears—in the Best Way
-
Republican Rep. Juan Ciscomani wins reelection to Arizona US House seat
-
Dallas Stars tie series with Edmonton Oilers, end Leon Draisaitl's point streak
-
Bird flu detected in beef tissue for first time, USDA says, but beef is safe to eat
-
Cracker Barrel CEO says brand isn't relevant and needs a new plan. Here are 3 changes coming soon.