Current:Home > StocksSupreme Court makes it easier to sue for job discrimination over forced transfers-LoTradeCoin
Supreme Court makes it easier to sue for job discrimination over forced transfers
View Date:2024-12-23 20:50:17
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Wednesday made it easier for workers who are transferred from one job to another against their will to pursue job discrimination claims under federal civil rights law, even when they are not demoted or docked pay.
Workers only have to show that the transfer resulted in some, but not necessarily significant, harm to prove their claims, Justice Elena Kagan wrote for the court.
The justices unanimously revived a sex discrimination lawsuit filed by a St. Louis police sergeant after she was forcibly transferred, but retained her rank and pay.
Sgt. Jaytonya Muldrow had worked for nine years in a plainclothes position in the department’s intelligence division before a new commander reassigned her to a uniformed position in which she supervised patrol officers. The new commander wanted a male officer in the intelligence job and sometimes called Muldrow “Mrs.” instead of “sergeant,” Kagan wrote.
Muldrow sued under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits workplace discrimination on the basis of race, sex, religion and national origin. Lower courts had dismissed Muldrow’s claim, concluding that she had not suffered a significant job disadvantage.
“Today, we disapprove that approach,” Kagan wrote. “Although an employee must show some harm from a forced transfer to prevail in a Title VII suit, she need not show that the injury satisfies a significance test.”
Kagan noted that many cases will come out differently under the lower bar the Supreme Court adopted Wednesday. She pointed to cases in which people lost discrimination suits, including those of an engineer whose new job site was a 14-by-22-foot wind tunnel, a shipping worker reassigned to exclusively nighttime work and a school principal who was forced into a new administrative role that was not based in a school.
Although the outcome was unanimous, Justices Samuel Alito, Brett Kavanaugh and Clarence Thomas each wrote separate opinions noting some level of disagreement with the majority’s rationale in ruling for Muldrow.
The decision revives Muldrow’s lawsuit, which now returns to lower courts. Muldrow contends that, because of sex discrimination, she was moved to a less prestigious job, which was primarily administrative and often required weekend work, and she lost her take-home city car.
“If those allegations are proved,” Kagan wrote, “she was left worse off several times over.”
The case is Muldrow v. St.Louis, 22-193.
veryGood! (94)
Related
- November 2024 full moon this week is a super moon and the beaver moon
- Fifty Years After the UN’s Stockholm Environment Conference, Leaders Struggle to Realize its Vision of ‘a Healthy Planet’
- Biden is counting on Shalanda Young to cut a spending deal Republicans can live with
- Yellen sets new deadline for Congress to raise the debt ceiling: June 5
- Jennifer Lopez Gets Loud in Her First Onstage Appearance Amid Ben Affleck Divorce
- A Teenage Floridian Has Spent Half His Life Involved in Climate Litigation. He’s Not Giving Up
- What has been driving inflation? Economists' thinking may have changed
- Ubiquitous ‘Forever Chemicals’ Increase Risk of Liver Cancer, Researchers Report
- Eva Longoria Shares She and Her Family Have Moved Out of the United States
- In Jacobabad, One of the Hottest Cities on the Planet, a Heat Wave Is Pushing the Limits of Human Livability
Ranking
- High-scoring night in NBA: Giannis Antetokounmpo explodes for 59, Victor Wembanyama for 50
- The dangers of money market funds
- Kathy Hilton Shares Cryptic Message Amid Sister Kyle Richards and Mauricio Umansky Divorce Rumors
- Residents and Environmentalists Say a Planned Warehouse District Outside Baltimore Threatens Wetlands and the Chesapeake Bay
- University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign chancellor to step down at end of academic year
- Max streaming service says it will restore writer and director credits after outcry
- See How Jennifer Lopez, Khloe Kardashian and More Stars Are Celebrating 4th of July
- An Orlando drag show restaurant files lawsuit against Florida and Gov. Ron DeSantis
Recommendation
-
The Latin Grammys are almost here for a 25th anniversary celebration
-
California Climate Measure Fails After ‘Green’ Governor Opposed It in a Campaign Supporters Called ‘Misleading’
-
The Botanic Matchmakers that Could Save Our Food Supply
-
A Vast Refinery Site in Philadelphia Is Being Redeveloped and Called ‘The Bellwether District.’ But for Black Residents Nearby, Justice Awaits
-
Blake Shelton Announces New Singing Competition Show After Leaving The Voice
-
Housing dilemma in resort towns
-
Tucker Carlson says he'll take his show to Twitter
-
Welcome to America! Now learn to be in debt