Current:Home > MarketsProposed protective order would infringe on Trump's free speech, his lawyers say-LoTradeCoin
Proposed protective order would infringe on Trump's free speech, his lawyers say
View Date:2024-12-23 21:22:09
Former President Donald Trump's legal team says that a protective order proposed by special counsel Jack Smith would infringe on Trump's right to free speech.
Trump's attorneys made the argument in their response Monday to the special counsel's motion for a protective order over the discovery evidence in the case against Trump for allegedly seeking to overturn the 2020 election.
Trump has pleaded not guilty to charges of undertaking a "criminal scheme" to overturn the results of the 2020 election by enlisting a slate of so-called "fake electors" targeting several states; using the Justice Department to conduct "sham election crime investigations"; and trying to enlist the vice president to "alter the election results" -- all in an effort to subvert democracy and remain in power.
MORE: Special counsel alerts court to Trump’s social media post
The former president has denied all wrongdoing and has dismissed the probe as politically motivated.
Monday's filing argues for narrower limits on the protective order, which Trump's attorneys say would protect sensitive materials while ensuring Trump's right to free speech.
"In a trial about First Amendment rights, the government seeks to restrict First Amendment rights," Trump's attorneys wrote in their filing. "Worse, it does so against its administration's primary political opponent, during an election season in which the administration, prominent party members, and media allies have campaigned on the indictment and proliferated its false allegations."
Smith's indictment against Trump, unsealed last week, disputes that he is being charged for exercising his First Amendment rights, instead alleging that he perpetrated three criminal conspiracies as "unlawful means of discounting legitimate votes and subverting the election results."
Smith asked the judge for the protective order on Friday, referencing a social media post Trump made Friday afternoon in which he said, "IF YOU GO AFTER ME, I'M COMING AFTER YOU!"
In a statement issued after Smith's filing on Friday, the Trump campaign said the post was aimed at political interest groups.
"The Truth post cited is the definition of political speech," a Trump spokesperson said in a statement.
The proposed protective order submitted by Smith does not seek to bar Trump from commenting on the case in its entirety, but would restrict Trump and his attorneys from disclosing evidence such as materials returned from grand jury subpoenas and testimony from witnesses and other exhibits shown to the grand jury. It does not limit Trump from discussing materials that were already available to the public separate from the government's investigation.
Smith's attorneys have said the proposed order is largely modeled after similar protective orders issued in other cases.
But in their filing on Monday, Trump's attorneys accuse Smith's team of asking Judge Tanya Chutkan to "assume the role of censor and impose content-based regulations on President Trump's political speech that would forbid him from publicly discussing or disclosing all non-public documents produced by the government, including both purportedly sensitive materials, and non-sensitive, potentially exculpatory documents."
MORE: Judge in Trump's Jan. 6 case gives attorneys 2 weeks to propose trial date
Trump "does not contest the government's claimed interest in restricting some of the documents it must produce" such as grand jury related materials -- but "the need to protect that information does not require a blanket gag order over all documents produced by the government," the filing says.
Judge Chutkan said in an order on Saturday that she would "determine whether to schedule a hearing to discuss the proposed protective order after reviewing Defendant's response."
veryGood! (113)
Related
- Black women notch historic Senate wins in an election year defined by potential firsts
- 14-year-old boy charged with murder after stabbing at NC school kills 1 student, injures another
- Widow of serial killer who preyed on virgins faces trial over cold cases
- Purdue is new No. 1 as top of USA TODAY Sports men's basketball poll gets reshuffled
- Get $103 Worth of Tatcha Skincare for $43.98 + 70% Off Flash Deals on Elemis, Josie Maran & More
- Texas abortion case goes before state's highest court, as more women join lawsuit
- Robert De Niro says Apple, Gotham Awards cut his anti-Trump speech: 'How dare they do that'
- Argentina’s right-wing president-elect to meet with a top Biden adviser
- Padma Lakshmi, John Boyega, Hunter Schafer star in Pirelli's 2025 calendar: See the photos
- What to expect from Mike Elko after Texas A&M hired Duke coach to replace Jimbo Fisher
Ranking
- Oprah Winfrey Addresses Claim She Was Paid $1 Million by Kamala Harris' Campaign
- Philippine government and communist rebels agree to resume talks to end a deadly protracted conflict
- Sierra Leone’s leader says most behind the weekend attacks are arrested, but few details are given
- Rosalynn Carter lies in repose in Atlanta as mourners pay their respects
- Kennesaw State football coach Brian Bohannon steps down after 10 seasons amid first year in FBS
- CEO, former TCU football player and his 2 children killed while traveling for Thanksgiving
- Greek officials angry and puzzled after UK’s Sunak scraps leaders’ meeting over Parthenon Marbles
- What is Young Thug being charged with? What to know as rapper's trial begin
Recommendation
-
School workers accused of giving special needs student with digestive issue hot Takis, other abuse
-
Jada Pinkett Smith Confirms Future of Her and Will Smith's Marriage After Separation Revelation
-
Who could be a fit for Carolina Panthers head coaching job? Here are 10 candidates to know
-
Nationwide curfew declared in Sierra Leone after attack on army barracks in capital city
-
When do new 'Yellowstone' episodes come out? Here's the Season 5, Part 2 episode schedule
-
One Tree Hill’s Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Where She Found “Safety” Amid Exit From Cult Life
-
Body of man reported missing Nov. 1 found in ventilation system of Michigan college building
-
Jill Biden unveils White House holiday decorations: 98 Christmas trees, 34K ornaments