Current:Home > ScamsA judge sided with publishers in a lawsuit over the Internet Archive's online library-LoTradeCoin
A judge sided with publishers in a lawsuit over the Internet Archive's online library
View Date:2024-12-23 18:29:59
A federal judge has ruled in favor of a group of book publishers who sued the nonprofit Internet Archive in the early days of the coronavirus pandemic for scanning and lending digital copies of copyrighted books.
The four publishing houses — Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins, John Wiley & Sons and Penguin Random House — accused the Internet Archive of "mass copyright infringement" for loaning out digital copies of books without compensation or permission from the publishers.
Though libraries typically license e-books from publishers, the Internet Archive said it practiced "controlled digital lending," which argues that entities that own physical copies of books can lend out scanned versions.
The Internet Archive, which strives to provide "universal access to all knowledge," said its online library is legal under the doctrine of fair use.
But on Friday, U.S. District Court Judge John G. Koeltl of the Southern District of New York sided with the publishers, saying established law was on their side.
"At bottom, IA's fair use defense rests on the notion that lawfully acquiring a copyrighted print book entitles the recipient to make an unauthorized copy and distribute it in place of the print book, so long as it does not simultaneously lend the print book," Koeltl said in his opinion.
"But no case or legal principle supports that notion. Every authority points the other direction."
Koeltl noted that the Internet Archive can still scan and publish copies of books that are in the public domain.
The Authors Guild, a professional organization for published writers, praised the ruling, saying that "scanning & lending books w/out permission or compensation is NOT fair use—it is theft & it devalues authors' works." The Association of American Publishers said the ruling reaffirmed the importance of copyright law.
The Internet Archive said it will appeal the ruling.
In a statement, Internet Archive founder Brewster Kahle suggested the judge's opinion would harm libraries, readers and authors.
"Libraries are more than the customer service departments for corporate database products," Kahle said. "For democracy to thrive at global scale, libraries must be able to sustain their historic role in society—owning, preserving, and lending books."
Part of the case involved the National Emergency Library, a temporary online collection established in 2020 that lent digital books while brick-and-mortar libraries were closed during COVID-19 lockdowns. It operated from March 24 to June 16 of that year.
With its other online collections, the Internet Archive had said it was lending out one digital copy of a book to one reader at a time, but the nonprofit suspended that policy for the National Emergency Library, allowing many readers to borrow the same book at once.
Authors have previously lobbed criticism at the Internet Archive, accusing the nonprofit of flouting well-established book lending rules and loaning out works without permission, thereby depriving writers of potential earnings.
The National Emergency Library was just one part of the Internet Archive, which is also known for its popular website archiving service, the Wayback Machine.
veryGood! (7196)
Related
- 2 credit unions in Mississippi and Louisiana are planning to merge
- Do narcissists feel heartbroken? It's complicated. What to know about narcissism, breakups.
- Taurine makes energy drinks more desirable. But is it safe?
- 'Slap in the face': West Maui set to reopen for tourism, with outrage from residents
- Maine dams face an uncertain future
- Patriots fan dies after 'incident' at Gillette Stadium, investigation underway
- Jurors, witnesses in synagogue massacre trial faced threats from this white supremacist
- College football is set for historic Week 4 with seven games matching ranked opponents
- Traveling to Las Vegas? Here Are the Best Black Friday Hotel Deals
- Lahaina's 150-year-old banyan tree that was charred by the wildfires is showing signs of new life
Ranking
- Rep. Michael McCaul of Texas says he was detained in airport over being ‘disoriented’
- Deion Sanders condemns death threats against player whose late hit left Hunter with lacerated liver
- Wisconsin redistricting fight focuses on the recusal of a key justice as impeachment threat lingers
- Biden gives U.N. speech urging the 2023 General Assembly to preserve peace, prevent conflict
- Veterans face challenges starting small businesses but there are plenty of resources to help
- West Point sued over using race as an admissions factor in the wake of landmark Supreme Court ruling
- Azerbaijan says it's halting offensive on disputed Armenian enclave
- Border communities see uptick in migrant arrivals in recent weeks: Officials
Recommendation
-
California man allegedly shot couple and set their bodies, Teslas on fire in desert
-
Will Lionel Messi play in Inter Miami's next match vs. Toronto FC? Here's the latest.
-
Tornado kills 5 people in eastern China
-
Wisconsin Legislature set to reject governor’s special session on child care, worker shortages
-
NFL Week 10 injury report: Live updates on active, inactive players for Sunday's games
-
Rihanna and A$AP Rocky debut newborn son Riot Rose in new photoshoot
-
Chicago Mayor Unveils Reforms to Fight Environmental Racism
-
British police officer is charged with murder of unarmed Black man in London