Current:Home > NewsBack off, FTC. Suing to stop Kroger-Albertsons merger exemplifies bumbling bureaucracy.-LoTradeCoin
Back off, FTC. Suing to stop Kroger-Albertsons merger exemplifies bumbling bureaucracy.
View Date:2024-12-23 20:20:11
Kroger wants to acquire Albertsons. The Federal Trade Commission wants to stop them.
Reasonable people can disagree about whether Kroger is making a good business decision – the price they’ll pay, about $25 billion, is a lot of money. But everybody who’s been paying attention to the way Americans eat should agree that the FTC’s lawsuit to block the deal is ridiculous.
If this were nothing more than a story of a risky, complicated merger and a clueless, bumbling bureaucracy, there wouldn’t be much more to say. Cincinnati-based Kroger is trying to make a living in a low-margin, high-competition business. Mergers and acquisitions are just part of their life. Everybody knows that.
The FTC has been filing silly cases since 1914. Everybody knows that, too.
Would Kroger-Albertsons merger drive up grocery prices?
But let’s think for a moment about what this soap opera on the business page reveals about the stunning transformation in the way we live our lives.
Start with FTC’s argument: Kroger and Albertsons are in the business of selling groceries. In certain parts of the country their markets overlap. If they merge, the FTC claims, there will be less competition and shoppers will end up paying higher prices.
Fix FDA's approval process:My daughter has a rare disease. We shouldn't have had to leave the US to save her.
That seems to make sense until you realize Kroger and Albertsons aren’t in the business of selling groceries, at least in the way we used to think of as the business selling groceries.
This means they don’t compete that much between each other.
Costco rotisserie chickens prove a point
To illustrate, go to Costco on Saturday and grab one of those hot dogs/soda combos, which sell for $1.50. Once you’ve added your complimentary relish, find a seat where you can see the checkout counter and count how many people come through with a roasted chicken.
You probably know this already, but lots of people like Costco chicken.
Whether Costco makes money selling chickens for $4.99 or whether the grocery chain's using them to get people into the store is beside the point. Costco, like any company, is in the business of selling people what they need. Costco's figured out that people don’t just need TVs, patio furniture and toilet paper.
People need to get their families fed, out the door and on with their lives. If you’ve got a two-hour break between your daughter’s soccer game and your son’s T-ball practice, the Costco cafe and ready-to-eat dinner meals solve two big problems.
Funny side of sunny economy:True MAGA patriots must remove themselves from Biden’s booming economy, cash out 401(k)s
Kroger knows this, too. Sure, these places still sell milk, eggs and bread. But they’re increasingly in the business of “meal solutions.” That means Kroger, and Albertons don’t just compete against each other (and Walmart, and Whole Foods, and Target, and regional grocery store chains and delivery services).
They’re competing against fast-food joints, takeout places and casual dining.
What’s interesting about all of this is not so much the fact that the grocery business has changed, but why the grocery business changed.
The answer depends on whom you ask. Some people say it’s because Americans have become rich and lazy. Others say it’s because Americans have become rich and busy.
Americans make more now than half a century ago
If you disagree, it’s probably because you don’t think you’re rich. Few of us do. But if someone 50 years ago could look at the way you live now, they’d think you’ve got it made.
In the 1970s, personal annual income, after adjusting for inflation, was about $18,000. Now it’s about $50,000. What’s even more remarkable is that we can use all that extra money to buy things that were simply unavailable then. Smartphones and computers are obvious examples, but Costco chickens weren’t available 50 years ago, either.
You can decide for yourself whether we’ve become lazy or busy. Either way, though, if you’re a typical American, you’re spending less time in the kitchen than ever. (One recent survey found that people were spending less than half the time cooking than their parents did.)
It’s hard to predict the outcome of this case. (Which is another problem. Businesses shouldn’t have to guess what’s allowed and what isn’t.) But whatever happens, it isn’t going to change the transformation that’s already swept the business of eating.
Kroger is trying to adjust. The FTC is trying to obstruct.
Michael L. Davis is an economics professor at the Cox School of Business at the Southern Methodist University in Dallas. This column first published in the Cincinnati Enquirer.
veryGood! (9)
Related
- Francesca Farago Details Health Complications That Led to Emergency C-Section of Twins
- Arizona county canvass starts recount process in tight Democratic primary in US House race
- Injured Ferguson police officer wanted to improve department ‘from the inside,’ ex-supervisor says
- Robert F. Kennedy Jr. can remain on the North Carolina presidential ballot, judge says
- Kyle Richards Shares an Amazing Bottega Dupe From Amazon Along With Her Favorite Fall Trends
- Massachusetts fugitive wanted for 1989 rapes arrested after 90-minute chase through LA
- California Gov. Gavin Newsom nudges school districts to restrict student cellphone use
- Maryland extends the contract of athletic director Damon Evans through June 2029
- Steelers' Mike Tomlin shuts down Jayden Daniels Lamar comparison: 'That's Mr. Jackson'
- When does 'The Challenge 40: Battle of the Eras' premiere? Cast, where to watch, stream
Ranking
- Ryan Reynolds Clarifies Taylor Swift’s Role as Godmother to His Kids With Blake Lively
- Julianne Hough Reflects on Death of Her Dogs With Ex Ryan Seacrest
- Why Post Malone Thinks It Would Suck to Be Taylor Swift or Beyoncé
- Jarren Duran suspended 2 games by Red Sox for shouting homophobic slur at fan who heckled him
- World leaders aim to shape Earth's future at COP29 climate change summit
- All qualifying North Carolina hospitals are joining debt-reduction effort, governor says
- Why Kylie Jenner Is Keeping Her Romance With Timothée Chalamet Private
- Takeaways from AP’s story on Alabama’s ecologically important Mobile-Tensaw Delta and its watershed
Recommendation
-
Trump breaks GOP losing streak in nation’s largest majority-Arab city with a pivotal final week
-
Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds mark first married couple to top box office in 34 years
-
Matt Kuchar bizarrely stops playing on 72nd hole of Wyndham Championship
-
3 people killed in fire that destroyed home in small town northeast of Seattle
-
Nicky Hilton Shares Her Christmas Plans With Paris, the Secret To Perfect Skin & More Holiday Gift Picks
-
New metal detectors delay students’ first day of school in one South Florida district
-
Pokémon Voice Actor Rachael Lillis Dead at 46
-
Los Angeles earthquake follows cluster of California temblors: 'Almost don't believe it'