Current:Home > BackKansas court’s reversal of a kidnapping conviction prompts a call for a new legal rule-LoTradeCoin
Kansas court’s reversal of a kidnapping conviction prompts a call for a new legal rule
View Date:2024-12-23 22:01:19
TOPEKA, Kan. (AP) — Three members of the Kansas Supreme Court want to make it easier for prosecutors to convict defendants of kidnapping, saying in a dissenting opinion Friday that the court should abandon a legal rule it has used for nearly 50 years in reviewing criminal cases.
The court issued a 4-3 decision in the case of a Finney County man convicted of aggravated kidnapping, aggravated rape and aggravated sodomy over a December 2018 attack on a woman in her home. While the court upheld Michael Wayne Couch’s other convictions, it reversed his kidnapping conviction.
The majority invoked a rule imposed in a 1976 decision that similarly involved multiple crimes. In that earlier case, the court declared that a defendant could not be convicted of kidnapping if the actions covered by that charge are “inherent” in another crime, are “slight or inconsequential” or have no “significance independently.”
The Supreme Court in 1976 gave examples. It said a robbery on the street does not involve kidnapping, but forcing the victim into an alley does. Moving a rape victim from room to room in a house for the rapist’s “convenience” is not kidnapping, but forcing the victim from a public place to a secluded one is.
According to the court’s opinion, Couch broke into the home of the victim, identified only as H.D., threatened her with a knife and forced her to move throughout the house. The majority concluded that moving the victim through the house did not “facilitate” Couch’s sex crimes by making them “substantially easier to commit” or helping to hide them.
But Justice Caleb Stegall said in a dissenting opinion that the 1976 rule is “difficult and cumbersome to apply” and goes against “plain and unambiguous” language in the law defining kidnapping as confining someone using force, threats or deception. He was joined in his dissent by Chief Justice Marla Luckert and Justice Evelyn Wilson, both former trial court judges.
“We have repeatedly recognized that the Legislature, not the courts, is the primary policy-making branch of the government and that it is not within our power to rewrite statutes to satisfy our policy preferences,” Stegall wrote. “In my view, vindicating these principles far outweighs continued adhearance to a wrongly decided and badly reasoned precedent.”
If a sex crime also is involved, a conviction in Kansas for aggravated kidnapping, or harming someone during a kidnapping, carries a penalty of at least 20 years in prison. Couch was sentenced to nearly 109 years in prison for all of his crimes.
The arguments among the seven justices in Kansas echoed arguments among U.S. Supreme Court members in a far different context in the Dobbs decision last year overturning Roe v. Wade and allowing states to outlaw abortion. Five conservative justices rejected arguments that the court should uphold Roe v. Wade because it was well-settled law, protecting access to abortion for nearly 50 years.
In Friday’s ruling, Kansas Justice K.J. Wall said the state’s appellate courts have long relied on the 1976 decision to decide whether a kidnapping occurred. Neither side in Couch’s case asked for it to be overruled, he wrote.
“And we have previously declined to reconsider precedent under similar circumstances,” Wall wrote. He was joined in the majority by Justices Dan Biles, Eric Rosen and Melissa Standridge. Rosen is a former trial court judge.
___
Follow John Hanna on Twitter: https://twitter.com/apjdhanna
veryGood! (97789)
Related
- Smithfield agrees to pay $2 million to resolve child labor allegations at Minnesota meat plant
- National Guard officer deployed to southern border given reprimand after pleading guilty to assault
- Accused Taylor Swift stalker arrested 3 times in 5 days outside of her NYC home
- New Jersey Transit is seeking a 15% fare hike that would be first increase in nearly a decade
- Are Ciara Ready and Russell Wilson Ready For Another Baby? She Says…
- Business Insider to lay off around 8% of employees in latest media job cuts
- EPA: Cancer-causing chemicals found in soil at north Louisiana apartment complex
- SAG-AFTRA defends Alec Baldwin as he faces a new charge in the 'Rust' fatal shooting
- Stop smartphone distractions by creating a focus mode: Video tutorial
- AP Week in Pictures: Europe and Africa
Ranking
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Something Corporate
- Oklahoma trooper hit, thrown in traffic stop as vehicle crashes into parked car: Watch
- Mislabeled cookies containing peanuts sold in Connecticut recalled after death of New York woman
- A Missouri nursing home shut down suddenly. A new report offers insight into the ensuing confusion
- Early Week 11 fantasy football rankings: 30 risers and fallers
- Golden syrup is a century-old sweetener in Britain. Here's why it's suddenly popular.
- Girlfriend of suspect in fatal shootings of 8 in Chicago suburb charged with obstruction, police say
- Mississippi ballot initiative proposal would not allow changes to abortion laws
Recommendation
-
Utah AD Mark Harlan rips officials following loss to BYU, claims game was 'stolen from us'
-
Music student from China convicted of harassing person over democracy leaflet
-
Salty: Tea advice from American chemist seeking the 'perfect' cup ignites British debate
-
Why Bachelor Nation's Susie Evans and Justin Glaze Decided to Finally Move Out of the Friend Zone
-
Tropical Storm Sara threatens to bring flash floods and mudslides to Central America
-
How Kobe Bryant Spread the Joy of Being a Girl Dad
-
Music student from China convicted of harassing person over democracy leaflet
-
Watch: Lionel Messi teases his first Super Bowl commercial