Current:Home > InvestLawyers fined for filing bogus case law created by ChatGPT-LoTradeCoin
Lawyers fined for filing bogus case law created by ChatGPT
View Date:2024-12-23 20:30:08
A federal judge on Thursday imposed $5,000 fines on two lawyers and a law firm in an unprecedented instance in which ChatGPT was blamed for their submission of fictitious legal research in an aviation injury claim.
Judge P. Kevin Castel said they acted in bad faith. But he credited their apologies and remedial steps taken in explaining why harsher sanctions were not necessary to ensure they or others won't again let artificial intelligence tools prompt them to produce fake legal history in their arguments.
"Technological advances are commonplace and there is nothing inherently improper about using a reliable artificial intelligence tool for assistance," Castel wrote. "But existing rules impose a gatekeeping role on attorneys to ensure the accuracy of their filings."
A Texas judge earlier this month ordered attorneys to attest that they would not use ChatGPT or other generative artificial intelligence technology to write legal briefs because the AI tool can invent facts.
The judge said the lawyers and their firm, Levidow, Levidow & Oberman, P.C., "abandoned their responsibilities when they submitted non-existent judicial opinions with fake quotes and citations created by the artificial intelligence tool ChatGPT, then continued to stand by the fake opinions after judicial orders called their existence into question."
- Texas judge bans filings solely created by AI after ChatGPT made up cases
- A lawyer used ChatGPT to prepare a court filing. It went horribly awry.
In a statement, the law firm said it would comply with Castel's order, but added: "We respectfully disagree with the finding that anyone at our firm acted in bad faith. We have already apologized to the Court and our client. We continue to believe that in the face of what even the Court acknowledged was an unprecedented situation, we made a good faith mistake in failing to believe that a piece of technology could be making up cases out of whole cloth."
The firm said it was considering whether to appeal.
Bogus cases
Castel said the bad faith resulted from the failures of the attorneys to respond properly to the judge and their legal adversaries when it was noticed that six legal cases listed to support their March 1 written arguments did not exist.
The judge cited "shifting and contradictory explanations" offered by attorney Steven A. Schwartz. He said attorney Peter LoDuca lied about being on vacation and was dishonest about confirming the truth of statements submitted to Castel.
At a hearing earlier this month, Schwartz said he used the artificial intelligence-powered chatbot to help him find legal precedents supporting a client's case against the Colombian airline Avianca for an injury incurred on a 2019 flight.
Microsoft has invested some $1 billion in OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT.
The chatbot, which generates essay-like answers to prompts from users, suggested several cases involving aviation mishaps that Schwartz hadn't been able to find through usual methods used at his law firm. Several of those cases weren't real, misidentified judges or involved airlines that didn't exist.
The made-up decisions included cases titled Martinez v. Delta Air Lines, Zicherman v. Korean Air Lines and Varghese v. China Southern Airlines.
The judge said one of the fake decisions generated by the chatbot "have some traits that are superficially consistent with actual judicial decisions" but he said other portions contained "gibberish" and were "nonsensical."
In a separate written opinion, the judge tossed out the underlying aviation claim, saying the statute of limitations had expired.
Lawyers for Schwartz and LoDuca did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
- In:
- Technology
veryGood! (5176)
Related
- NASCAR Cup Series Championship race 2024: Start time, TV, live stream, odds, lineup
- Cause of death for Adam Rich, former Eight is Enough child star, ruled as fentanyl
- Here's What You Missed Since Glee: Inside the Cast's Real Love Lives
- What to Make of Some Young Evangelicals Abandoning Trump Over Climate Change?
- Cold case arrest: Florida man being held in decades-old Massachusetts double murder
- Emissions of Nitrous Oxide, a Climate Super-Pollutant, Are Rising Fast on a Worst-Case Trajectory
- Amazon Reviewers Swear By These 15 Affordable Renter-Friendly Products
- Ohio River May Lose Its Regional Water Quality Standards, Vote Suggests
- 2 striking teacher unions in Massachusetts face growing fines for refusing to return to classroom
- Titan sub implosion highlights extreme tourism boom, but adventure can bring peril
Ranking
- New Orleans marks with parade the 64th anniversary of 4 little girls integrating city schools
- Hawaii Eyes Offshore Wind to Reach its 100 Percent Clean Energy Goal
- New federal rules will limit miners' exposure to deadly disease-causing dust
- Is gun violence an epidemic in the U.S.? Experts and history say it is
- FBI offers up to $25,000 reward for information about suspect behind Northwest ballot box fires
- Ohio man accused of killing his 3 sons indicted, could face death penalty
- In Dozens of Cities East of the Mississippi, Winter Never Really Happened
- Peru is reeling from record case counts of dengue fever. What's driving the outbreak?
Recommendation
-
Jennifer Hudson, Kylie Minogue and Billy Porter to perform at Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade
-
Trump and Biden Diverged Widely and Wildly During the Debate’s Donnybrook on Climate Change
-
'We're not doing that': A Black couple won't crowdfund to pay medical debt
-
Special counsel asks for December trial in Trump documents case
-
2025 Medicare Part B premium increase outpaces both Social Security COLA and inflation
-
Defense arguments are set to open in a landmark climate case brought by Montana youth
-
24-Hour Ulta Deal: 50% Off a Bio Ionic Iron That Curls or Straightens Hair in Less Than 10 Minutes
-
A smarter way to use sunscreen