Current:Home > StocksDetroit cops overhaul facial recognition policies after rotten arrest-LoTradeCoin
Detroit cops overhaul facial recognition policies after rotten arrest
View Date:2024-12-23 16:50:43
The Detroit Police Department revised its policies on how it uses facial recognition software to solve crimes as part of a federal settlement with a man who was wrongfully arrested for theft in 2020 based on the technology, authorities said Friday.
Robert Williams was falsely identified as the shoplifter at a Shinola store in October 2018. Fifteen months later, he was arrested in front of his family in his driveway, booked in jail and held for 30 hours before he was released on a personal bond, according to his lawsuit.
The settlement between Williams and the city of Detroit was filed in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan on Friday. Previously, in May, the Detroit City Council approved paying Williams $300,000 for damages as part of the settlement.
A Detroit detective ran a grainy photo made from poorly lit footage through the department's facial recognition technology, Williams' lawsuit states. In the footage, the shoplifter never looks directly into the camera, the lawsuit said.
The detective sent the poor quality photo to the Michigan State Police to run a face recognition technology search, which returned a possible match to an expired driver’s license photo of Mr. Williams, according to the American Civil Liberties Union.
City officials cited "sloppy" detective work for the wrongful arrest, cleared Williams' record and removed his personal information from the police database.
Williams said abuse of facial recognition technology "completely upended my life."
"My wife and young daughters had to watch helplessly as I was arrested for a crime I didn't commit and by the time I got home from jail, I had already missed my youngest losing her first tooth and my eldest couldn't even bear to look at my picture. Even now, years later, it still brings them to tears when they think about it," he said in a statement.
“The scariest part is that what happened to me could have happened to anyone."
National civil rights advocates have decried law enforcement use of the technology for its hazardous misidentifications. At least seven people have been wrongfully arrested across the nation due to "police reliance on incorrect face recognition results," the ACLU said in April. Nearly all of the falsely accused people were Black. Three of the cases were in Detroit, including a woman who was eight months pregnant at the time and arrested in front of her children, the ACLU said.
ACLU: New Detroit policy serves as model for departments across U.S.
The ACLU of Michigan, which sued on behalf of Williams, announced the Detroit police policy changes at a Friday news conference. Among them:
- Police can't make arrests based on facial recognition results alone, or on the results of photo lineups based on a facial recognition search.
- Police can't conduct lineups based on facial recognition alone without other independent, reliable evidence linking the suspect to a crime.
- Police must disclose the flaws of facial recognition technology and when it is used in an arrest. Officers must also disclose when facial recognition technology did not come up with a suspect, or when the results showed different suspects.
- Training on facial recognition software that includes risks and dangers of the technology and the disproportionate rate in which people of color are misidentified.
- An audit must be conducted of all cases since 2017 where Detroit police used facial recognition technology to get an arrest warrant.
Policies will be enforced by federal court for four years, the ACLU said. Representatives with the nonprofit group described the controversial facial recognition technology as "dangerous" and the settlement as "groundbreaking."
The new policies in Detroit will serve as a model for other police agencies nationally on best practices of facial recognition technology, said Phil Mayor, senior staff attorney at the ACLU of Michigan.
Detroit police said Friday that the department is pleased with the policy changes, and that it also "firmly" believes it will serve as a national example of best facial recognition practices.
"While the work DPD and the ACLU do may differ, our goals are similar — to ensure policing is done in a fair, equitable, and constitutional manner," the department wrote.
Following Williams' wrongful arrest, Detroit police created a facial recognition policy that included three independent sign-offs before the technology can be approved to use in an investigation, the department said. The policy also stated the technology could not be used as the basis for identifying a suspect.
Use of facial recognition software raises questions
A facial recognition system uses biometric software to map a person’s facial features from a video or photo. The system then tries to match the information on databases to verify someone’s identity.
Police departments use facial recognition to find potential crime suspects and witnesses by scanning through millions of photos. The software is also used to provide surveillance at public venues such as concerts and schools.
But the technology has raised opposition across the U.S. for misidentifying suspects – and the grave consequences that follow.
A Texas man wrongfully arrested and jailed for nearly two weeks filed a lawsuit in January that blamed facial recognition software for misidentifying him as the suspect in a store robbery. Using low-quality surveillance footage of the robbery, artificial intelligence software at a Sunglass Hut in Houston falsely identified Harvey Murphy Jr. as a suspect, which led to a warrant for his arrest, according to the lawsuit.
In August, Detroit police strengthened its photo lineup and facial recognition technology policies after "shoddy" police work led to the wrongful arrest of a pregnant woman, Police Chief James White previously said. Porcha Woodruff filed a federal lawsuit after she was wrongfully arrested in a carjacking and robbery.
The Federal Trade Commission in December banned Rite Aid from using AI facial recognition technology, accusing the pharmacy chain of recklessly deploying technology that subjected customers – especially people of color and women – to unwarranted searches.
The move came after Rite Aid deployed AI-based facial recognition to identify customers deemed likely to engage in criminal behavior such as shoplifting. The FTC said the technology often based its alerts on low-quality images, such as those from security cameras, phone cameras and news stories, resulting in thousands of "false-positive matches" and customers being searched or kicked out of stores for crimes they did not commit.
Contributing: Terry Collins and Bailey Schulz
Andrea Sahouri covers criminal justice for the Detroit Free Press, part of the USA TODAY Network. She can be contacted at[email protected].
veryGood! (77623)
Related
- Advance Auto Parts is closing hundreds of stores in an effort to turn its business around
- Craig Kimbrel melts down as Diamondbacks rally to beat Phillies, even up NLCS
- Undefeated No. 3 Buckeyes and No. 7 Nittany Lions clash in toughest test yet for Big Ten East rivals
- Mother arrested after dead newborn found in garbage bin behind Alabama convenience store
- Padma Lakshmi, John Boyega, Hunter Schafer star in Pirelli's 2025 calendar: See the photos
- Pacific and Atlantic hurricanes Norma and Tammy make landfall on Saturday in Mexico and Barbuda
- They were Sam Bankman-Fried's friends. Now they could send him to prison for life
- Hunter Biden special counsel David Weiss to speak with congressional investigators
- Target will be closed on Thanksgiving: Here’s when stores open on Black Friday
- The recipe for a better 'Bake-Off'? Fun format, good casting, and less host shtick
Ranking
- Kendall Jenner Is Back to Being a Brunette After Ditching Blonde Hair
- Storm hits northern Europe, killing at least 4 people
- A 5.2 magnitude earthquake in Nepal damages dozens of homes and causes a landslide
- Upgrade Your Home With Early Way Day Deals: Get a $720 Rug for $112, $733 Bed Frame for $220 & More
- Nicky Hilton Shares Her Christmas Plans With Paris, the Secret To Perfect Skin & More Holiday Gift Picks
- A spookier season: These 10 states are the most Halloween-obsessed in the US, survey shows
- Soccer fans flock to Old Trafford to pay tribute to Bobby Charlton following his death at age 86
- NASCAR Homestead-Miami playoff race 2023: Start time, TV, streaming, lineup for 4EVER 400
Recommendation
-
Miami Marlins hiring Los Angeles Dodgers first base coach Clayton McCullough as manager
-
Thousands of pro-Palestinian demonstrators march in London as Israel-Hamas war roils the world
-
Should USC and Ohio State be worried? Bold predictions for Week 8 in college football
-
Kim Kardashian Showcases Red Hot Style as She Celebrates 43rd Birthday With Family and Friends
-
Pistons' Tim Hardaway Jr. leaves in wheelchair after banging head on court
-
Last Chance: Save Up to 90% Off on Kate Spade Outlet Crossbodies, Shoulder Bags, Jewelry & More
-
College football Week 8 highlights: Catch up on all the scores, best plays and biggest wins
-
UAW chief Shawn Fain says latest offers show automakers have money left to spend