Current:Home > FinanceGOP-led House panel accuses cybersecurity agency of violating citizens' civil liberties-LoTradeCoin
GOP-led House panel accuses cybersecurity agency of violating citizens' civil liberties
View Date:2024-12-23 20:53:40
The federal government agency charged with protecting critical infrastructure and guarding against cybersecurity threats is accused of "exceeding its statutory authority" in its post-2016-election efforts to monitor domestic social media for evidence of misinformation, disinformation and malinformation, according to a House Republican-led committee's interim report.
The House Judiciary Committee and Subcommittee on Weaponization of the Federal Government issued a report accusing the Critical Infrastructure and Cybersecurity Agency, or CISA, of facilitating the "censorship of Americans directly and through third-party intermediaries." The committee's investigation cites internal Department of Homeland Security emails and meeting notes.
The core claims of the 41-page report focus on changes at the agency since the 2016 election. A January 2017 report from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence found Russian efforts to influence the election "demonstrated a significant escalation in directness, level of activity, and scope of effort compared to previous operations." The report did not assess "the impact that Russian activities had on the outcome of the 2016 election."
The House Judiciary Committee's report, peppered with politically charged language, alleges that CISA expanded the monitoring of foreign "disinformation" to "all disinformation including Americans' speech."
House Republicans say concern about CISA's expanded mandate and overwhelmingly negative backlash from DHS' Disinformation Governance Board prompted the department to begin "scrubbing CISA's website of references to domestic 'misinformation' and 'disinformation.'"
Some election officials expressed concern about the agency's involvement with domestic speech related to elections, the committee said, citing the CISA documents. According to the report, on August 2, 2022, an official with the National Association of Secretaries of State (NASS) warned "that it is important for CISA to remain within their operational and mission limits. CISA specifically should stick with misinformation and disinformation as related to cybersecurity issues."
The report also alleges that even within DHS, some were worried about how its expanded activities would ultimately be viewed.
The report alleges a May 2022 email from Suzanne Spaulding, a former senior intelligence official who worked on the project, to a colleague about the increased public attention on the matter. According to the report, Spaulding wrote, "It's only a matter of time before someone starts asking about our work... I'm not sure this keeps until our public meeting in June."
Dr. Kate Starbird, identified in the report as the co-founder of the University of Washington's Center for an Informed Public, responded to Spaulding, writing, "Yes. I agree. We have a couple of pretty obvious vulnerabilities."
The GOP-led committee and subcommittee take issue with attempts by the government to workshop ways to curb the domestic spread of misinformation and disinformation – led by the "Protecting Critical Infrastructure from Misinformation & Disinformation" Subcommittee. That committee, a voluntary group that served in an advisory role for CISA, was ultimately disbanded, according to the report, but not before issuing two sets of formal recommendations in June and September 2022.
In response to the "political environment and legal risks," congressional investigators write that Starbird also noted in a May 2022 email that the MDM Committee "removed 'monitoring' from just about every place where it appeared" in their recommendations.
In a statement to CBS News, Starbird wrote that the committee's report "grossly misrepresented" her work and that of the advisory board.
"This report disregards clarifying information within the broader record of our subcommittee's communications and final recommendations — as well as my voluntary testimony to this Committee — to push a misleading narrative of censorship," said Starbird. "Our subcommittee played no role in censoring any speech, nor did we advocate for the social media platforms to take any action to limit the spread of speech."
CISA Executive Director Brandon Wales said in a statement, "CISA does not and has never censored speech or facilitated censorship; any such claims are patently false."
"Every day, the men and women of CISA execute the agency's mission of reducing risk to U.S. critical infrastructure in a way that protects Americans' freedom of speech, civil rights, civil liberties, and privacy," Wales continued. "In response to concerns from election officials of all parties regarding foreign influence operations and disinformation that may impact the security of election infrastructure, CISA mitigates the risk of disinformation by sharing information on election literacy and election security with the public and by amplifying the trusted voices of election officials across the nation."
The committee's report argues, "Labeling speech 'misinformation' does not strip it of First Amendment protection. That is so even if the speech is untrue, as "[s]ome false statements are inevitable if there is to be an open and vigorous expression of views in public and private conversation."
Catherine HerridgeCatherine Herridge is a senior investigative correspondent for CBS News covering national security and intelligence based in Washington, D.C.
TwitterveryGood! (9562)
Related
- The Best Corduroy Pants Deals from J.Crew Outlet, Old Navy, Levi’s & More, Starting at $26
- Wendy Williams’ Family Speaks Out Amid Her Health and Addiction Struggles
- Discover's merger with Capital One may mean luxe lounges, better service, plus more perks
- After 2-year-old girl shoots self, man becomes first person charged under Michigan’s gun storage law
- Mike Tyson emerges as heavyweight champ among product pitchmen before Jake Paul fight
- Indiana lawmakers join GOP-led states trying to target college tenure
- Some international flights are exceeding 800 mph due to high winds. One flight arrived almost an hour early.
- Federal student loans for nearly 153,000 borrowers are being automatically canceled, Biden says
- What is ‘Doge’? Explaining the meme and cryptocurrency after Elon Musk's appointment to D.O.G.E.
- Hunter Biden’s lawyers suggest his case is tainted by claims of ex-FBI informant charged with lying
Ranking
- Princess Kate to host annual Christmas carol service following cancer treatment
- Usher Reveals Swizz Beatz’ Reaction to Super Bowl Performance With Alicia Keys
- Master All Four Elements With This Avatar: The Last Airbender Gift Guide
- What is the birthstone for March? There's actually 2. Get to know the spring month's gems.
- New York eyes reviving congestion pricing toll before Trump takes office
- Kelly Rowland’s Rep Speaks Out Amid Dressing Room Debacle
- Tom Sandoval apologizes for comparing 'Vanderpump Rules' scandal to O.J. Simpson, George Floyd
- Travis Kelce Touches Down in Australia to Reunite With Girlfriend Taylor Swift
Recommendation
-
Biden funded new factories and infrastructure projects, but Trump might get to cut the ribbons
-
A search is underway for a missing 3-year-old Wisconsin boy
-
Russia spy chief calls military pilot who defected to Ukraine a moral corpse after reported murder in Spain
-
A secret text code can help loved ones in an emergency: Here's how to set one up
-
US wholesale inflation picks up slightly in sign that some price pressures remain elevated
-
Hoda Kotb says she wants Kelly Rowland to 'come back' after singer's 'Today' show departure
-
Solange toys with the idea of a tuba album: 'I can only imagine the eye rolls'
-
A sand hole collapse in Florida killed a child. Such deaths occur several times a year in the US