Current:Home > BackDr. Tim Johnson on finding a middle-ground in the abortion debate-LoTradeCoin
Dr. Tim Johnson on finding a middle-ground in the abortion debate
View Date:2024-12-23 15:22:05
Last Tuesday, voters in Ohio became the latest to enshrine reproductive rights into their state constitution … which prompts thoughts on this deeply divisive issue from Dr. Tim Johnson:
I am a Protestant minister who became an emergency room doctor and then medical editor for ABC News for 25 years. In all those positions, I saw firsthand the impact of abortion on individual lives and families.
And I have concluded that the best way to think about abortion – and to achieve possible compromise — is to be both anti-abortion and pro-choice.
Most of us are instinctively anti-abortion. I personally have never met anyone who thinks it is a trivial procedure.
And since most abortions result from unwanted pregnancies, the logical answer is to make contraceptive birth control measures widely and affordably available. If you are anti-abortion, you must also be pro-birth control.
Being pro-choice is far more complicated. It involves the emotional issue of when life begins, and what choices are accordingly morally acceptable. When does life in the womb reach a stage when abortion would be more logically thought of as "murder" or "evil," and therefore prohibited? For many of us, that stage occurs when the developing fetus is capable of living on its own outside the womb.
And I do support women who, before that stage, thoughtfully conclude that another life to support will be destructive to her and/or her family.
A classic example is a mother already overwhelmed by poverty. If states insist on compelling women to carry to term, they must provide resources for adoption or other child support after birth. Otherwise, they are simply pro-birth, and not pro-life.
I also vigorously disagree with those who would force a woman to experience the terrible trauma of completing a pregnancy caused by incest or rape.
Finally, I do believe that abortion is a decision best made by a woman and her family – not by a group of strangers (usually men) making legislative or legal decisions. Under our clear constitutional separation of church and state, it certainly should not be made by those in power based on their own religious beliefs. We are all entitled to our own religious considerations, but we should not impose them by law on others who may believe very differently.
- Supreme Court strikes down Roe v. Wade in seismic shift for abortion rights
- Ohio voters enshrine abortion rights in state constitution
- Ohio GOP lawmakers vow to target state judiciary after passage of Issue 1 abortion measure
In short, a possible compromise to our abortion debate could be to unite in supporting birth control to prevent unwanted pregnancies, while also preserving the right of women to make difficult choices affecting them and their families.
That is a strategy that people with both anti-abortion and pro-choice views should embrace.
Story produced by Robert Marston. Editor: Chad Cardin.
- In:
- Abortion
veryGood! (3167)
Related
- Judge recuses himself in Arizona fake elector case after urging response to attacks on Kamala Harris
- Navy identifies U.S. sailor lost overboard in Red Sea
- Mercedes-Benz, Hyundai, Kia, Chrysler among 612K vehicles recalled: Check car recalls here
- Colorado university hires 2 former US attorneys to review shooting, recommend any changes
- Caitlin Clark shanks tee shot, nearly hits fans at LPGA's The Annika pro-am
- 18 dead frozen puppies discovered in Oregon home were meant as snake food, officials say
- New York City’s mayor cancels a border trip, citing safety concerns in Mexico
- Navy identifies U.S. sailor lost overboard in Red Sea
- Ariana Grande Shares Dad's Emotional Reaction to Using His Last Name in Wicked Credits
- At least 40 killed and dozens injured in Moscow concert hall shooting; ISIS claims responsibility
Ranking
- American arrested in death of another American at luxury hotel in Ireland
- You're throwing money away without a 401(k). Here's how to start saving for retirement.
- Anne Hathaway says she missed out on roles due to 'toxic' Hathahate backlash
- SCOTUS to hear arguments about mifepristone. The impact could go far beyond abortion, experts say
- Deion Sanders says he would prevent Shedeur Sanders from going to wrong team in NFL draft
- John Tucker Must Die Stars Confirm Sequel Is in the Works 18 Years Later
- Is the war on drugs back on? | The Excerpt podcast
- Women’s March Madness Sunday recap: No. 2 Stanford survives ISU in OT; No. 1 South Carolina rolls
Recommendation
-
Jennifer Lopez Gets Loud in Her First Onstage Appearance Amid Ben Affleck Divorce
-
NBA suspends Kris Dunn, Jabari Smith for role in fight during Rockets-Jazz game
-
Lil Jon swaps crunk for calm with new album Total Meditation
-
Spring Into Style With the Best Plus Size Fashion Deals From Amazon: Leggings, Dresses, Workwear & More
-
John Krasinski Reveals Wife Emily Blunt's Hilarious Response to His Sexiest Man Alive Title
-
Laurent de Brunhoff, Babar heir who created global media empire, dies at 98
-
Drag queen story hour canceled at Lancaster Public Library over package, bomb threats
-
Here's how long you have to keep working to get the most money from Social Security