Current:Home > BackHeartland Launches Website of Contrarian Climate Science Amid Struggles With Funding and Controversy-LoTradeCoin
Heartland Launches Website of Contrarian Climate Science Amid Struggles With Funding and Controversy
View Date:2024-12-23 23:40:58
The conservative Heartland Institute, which made its name undercutting mainstream climate science, has launched a new effort to try to influence public discussion and political debate about global warming.
The move comes as the organization is reportedly struggling financially and has fallen into renewed controversy over its work in Europe promoting climate denial there. Last week it laid off staff just weeks after it announced the hiring of a teenage German climate skeptic to counter the global popularity of environmental activist Greta Thunberg.
The new website, called Climate at a Glance, includes brief explanations of key climate science and policy issues, many of which are either misleading or inaccurate.
“It’s attempting to emulate a more scientific website than previously,” said Robert Brulle, a visiting professor at Brown University who has studied public relations campaigns by the fossil fuel industry. “Other than that it’s still the same sort of systematic distortion.”
An explainer of a carbon tax, for example, claims wind and solar power are “already very expensive.” In fact, those sources of energy are now competitive with or even cheaper than new coal or natural gas plants. A discussion of sea level rise claims that “there has been very little recent acceleration.” In truth, the rate of rise has more than doubled in recent years compared to during most of the 20th century.
The website comes amid evidence that the clout of Heartland and other groups that have promoted skepticism about climate change may be waning. An increasing number of Republican politicians have sought to distance themselves from climate denial. Last month, House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy of California, a Republican, introduced a package of bills to promote carbon capture and sequestration technology. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska), in her final year as chair of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, has been attempting to lead a bipartisan effort to pass energy efficiency and technology investment.
“I think they’re becoming more and more marginal,” Brulle said of Heartland, noting that some major corporate funders such as ExxonMobil distanced themselves from the group years ago. “You have all the big fossil fuel companies, they’re not attacking climate science any more.”
Last week’s layoff was part of what Heartland called a reorganization. But the HuffPost reported that the downsizing of “more than half” the staff was a result of financial problems for the organization. Their report said it was primarily mismanagement, rather than falling revenue, that led to the problems. In recent years, the group’s funders have included hedge fund billionaire Robert Mercer, who was President Donald Trump’s largest campaign donor in 2016.
It was just the latest bad news for the Illinois-based organization. In February, European journalists published an investigation about Heartland’s efforts to sow its climate denial in Europe. The journalists went undercover, posing as public relations consultants working for clients in the energy and auto industries. The report detailed Heartland’s methods for channeling donations through a third party, and “how disinformation is professionally scattered around society.”
Heartland did not reply to email or phone requests for comment for this article.
The organization has also come under fire for its hiring of a 19-year-old German woman to serve as the face of a new campaign against what it calls “climate alarmism.” Naomi Seibt, a YouTube star, has been criticized for her ties to Germany’s far-right and for comments that some challenged as anti-Semitic.
The new website is not Heartland’s first attempt to inject its materials about climate science into public discourse. And interviews suggest that, at least to an extent, the organization may be achieving at least some of its goal of spreading doubt.
Heartland has been trying to influence science curricula in schools for years. In 2017, it sent hundreds of thousands of copies of its publication “Why Scientists Disagree About Global Warming” to teachers around the country.
One of the recipients was Jane Ramos, who teaches 8th grade science at Vincent J. Gallagher Middle School in Smithfield, Rhode Island. She said she’s never used it with her students, but has referred to it on her own and was struck by its tone, which she found misleading.
“They take something that seems quite straightforward, and then they make you say, ‘Oh wait a minute,’” she said. “They put out all these other facts that sound so scientific, and I feel like it muddies the waters.”
Michael Whaley, who teaches environmental science at Pendleton High School and at Tri-County Technical College in South Carolina, said he has used the materials as “a conversation starter.” He said he thinks all sources are biased, so he has pointed his students to Heartland’s materials as an example of one side of the story.
“I do like what Heartland is doing, because they do call attention to it,” he said. “I think what you see in the media is heavily biased more towards alarmism. No matter where you look it’s easier to find that stuff, so they’re playing a role in at least keeping it even.”
While the new website’s launch comes amid Heartland’s latest controversies and financial problems, the organization registered the website last summer, before any of this was news.
In this light, the campaign may be the latest sign, along with the hiring of Seibt, that Heartland is shifting its messaging. The climate movement and public discourse about global warming have changed dramatically over the past 18 months.
Millions of students and activists have taken to the streets, lawmakers have introduced the first piece of a Green New Deal, and even Republican leaders have begun to move away from Heartland’s old line.
It’s not surprising that the institute would fall back on tactics that have worked well for it in the past, but it’s unclear if those will be as effective in this new landscape.
veryGood! (82668)
Related
- Fire crews on both US coasts battle wildfires, 1 dead; Veterans Day ceremony postponed
- Metal detectorist finds very rare ancient gold coin in Norway — over 1,600 miles away from its origin
- Juanita Castro, anti-communist sister of Cuban leaders Fidel and Raul, dies in Miami at 90
- The Excerpt podcast: Candidates get set for fourth Republican primary debate
- Halle Berry Rocks Sheer Dress She Wore to 2002 Oscars 22 Years Later
- EV tax credit for certain Tesla models may be smaller in 2024. Which models are at risk?
- Colorado Supreme Court will hear arguments on removing Trump from ballot under insurrection clause
- Aaron Rodgers defends Zach Wilson, rails against report saying Jets QB was reluctant to start again
- Stock market today: Asian stocks decline as China stimulus plan disappoints markets
- EV tax credit for certain Tesla models may be smaller in 2024. Which models are at risk?
Ranking
- Statue of the late US Rep. John Lewis, a civil rights icon, is unveiled in his native Alabama
- President Joe Biden and the White House support Indigenous lacrosse team for the 2028 Olympics
- Biden’s campaign will not commit yet to participating in general election debates in 2024
- 52 sea turtles experiencing ‘cold stun’ in New England flown to rehab in Florida
- Wildfires burn from coast-to-coast; red flag warnings issued for Northeast
- Activists say their voices are stifled by increasing rules and restrictions at COP28 climate talks
- In a year of book bans, Maureen Corrigan's top 10 affirm the joy of reading widely
- As Israel-Hamas war expands, U.S. pledges more aid for Palestinians, including a field hospital inside Gaza
Recommendation
-
Opinion: NFL began season with no Black offensive coordinators, first time since the 1980s
-
Two students arrested after bringing guns to California high school on consecutive days: Police
-
Fantasia Barrino Reflects on Losing Everything Twice Amid Oscar Buzz
-
US Coast Guard service members don’t feel safe, new review says. Officials are promising changes
-
Love Is Blind’s Chelsea Blackwell Reacts to Megan Fox’s Baby News
-
Jury acquits officer in Maryland county’s first police murder charge in shooting handcuffed man
-
The US is poised to require foreign aircraft-repair shops to test workers for drugs and alcohol
-
Attacks in 2 Texas cities leave 6 dead, 2 officers wounded; suspect in custody